The deaths aren’t in dispute. One could argue that these eight weren’t necessarily entirely innocent. But the defense isn’t making that case.
What’s likely is that the insurgents fled from house to house, leaving civilians behind to take the response to their attack. Of course, the Marines had no way of knowing that at the time. The insurgents could have made a stand in either house.
Interesting twist to this whole story with Salinas claiming to be in charge that day.
Puckett and Faraj
A former Corporal took the stand today insisting he was the Squad Leader, taking over those duties from the Sgt Wuterich that day because Sgt Wuterich was selected for promotion and was to be transferred soon. Others testified that normally, the Squad Leader is the Assistant Driver in a Vehicle with the hardwired radio. The former Cpl was in that position on November 19, 2005 and unequivocally stated he was the Squad Leader, and Sgt Wuterich was along on the patrol acting only as a driver.
According to this source,
Wuterich Squad Mate Maintains He Was in Charge of Haditha Convoy
Salias' testimony raises questions about who was in charge that day and whether Wuterich can be found guilty of dereliction of duty.
Interesting.
Yes, that's what I meant...the “innocents” part. ( since he said 8 “more”, he assumes the 6 in house 1 are also innocent)
Your scenario is likely.
thanks