Posted on 03/29/2014 6:37:20 PM PDT by Evil Slayer
We have a California Redwood framed craftsman. Bolted to the foundations, you’re absolutely right.
I was in a high rise downtown a few years ago during a Whittier Narrows 5 or so. It swayed and we could definitely feel it, but the quake was relatively light and still some distance off. Though I have a feeling most modern high-rise structures would ride fairly well, even in significantly larger events. Look at Tokyo during their big shaker.
not arguing Calif being a bear on building codes, but I think in your estimation of stickbuilts withstanding a “10” you neglected to consider earth movement.
Yesterday’s 5.1 caused foundation slab cracks significant enough to red-tag some apartments. In 94, the 6.7 Northridge quake cracked foundations of stickbuilts in Woodland Hills and Thousand Oaks (and probably more areas-these are just two people I knew). The 6.9 Loma Prieta quake in the Bay Area damaged 12,000 homes. Even a modular home can twist and warp from earth movement, and they’re built better than stickbuilts. That stickbuilt house may stand, but it’s not going to be much use when the bedroom is 2 feet higher than the front door, which is now 6 inches wider at the base post-earthquake.
Earthquakes aren’t just about shaking a structure, they’re about how far and which way the earth moves underneath a structure and how well that structure’s foundation bounces, and that’s something they can’t show you on Mythbusters :)
I didn't say the house would necessarily end up in good condition, but it will not fall in on itself. Most new home construction is wood frame stucco. The frame is wrapped in chicken wire and then covered in stucco and it may twist and crack a lot, but bringing it down is almost impossible.
The roof tiles will likely come flying off, which means you shouldn't run outside while the house is shaking but as long as you aren't standing under a chandelier or a loose bookcase, you are probably going to walk out of the house after it is over. You can't say the same thing about a tornado.
Strange....It always seems to be the religious types hoping for death and destruction by way of quakes, tornadoes and hurricanes.
Strangely, some non-religious types sit around waiting for a religious person to make such a statement, to pounce on him. Its like they have their radar on for this, when everyone else is paying attention to the disaster itself.
No they don’t. People that make ludicrous comments should expect heat.
BTW, what disaster are you talking about?
These quake have produced some shorted out nerves, but it’s certainly has not been a disaster by any description at this point.
If you say so.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.