I’m not understanding this at all. I-9s (Homeland Security doc# OBM1615-0047) have been a mandated element of business records since 1986. A list of documents that establish identity and work eligibility is given to each hire candidate (list A, list B or List C) who makes his/her own selection of what original documents to present. The employer doesn’t make up the list, DHS does. Why is this meatpacker being singled-out for complying with Homeland Security/IRS law? And how is it NOT discrimination against citizens to allow illegals to have job preference? (is the DOJ action a form of affirmative action for illegals?)
The employee is supposed to be the one who picks out the form of ID from list A or list B and list C. It says right on the I-9: "Employers cannot specify which document(s) employees may present from the Lists of Acceptable Documents, found on the last page of Form I-9, to establish identity and employment authorization."