[Lurking Libertarian]

This ruling demands that she affirmatively act in opposition to her religion. The equivalent would be a court ordering a doctor to perform an abortion.

The equivalent would be ordering an Amish County Clerk to issue a driver's license. Or ordering a Catholic County Clerk to issue a marriage license to someone who's been divorced. Or ordering a Quaker County Clerk to issue a gun permit.

[mrsmith]

Those are acts the authors and ratifiers of the Constitution would not find repugnant.

That he courts enforce laws repugnant to them, on the basis of their intent, is a recipe for disorder.