Posted on 05/30/2016 8:34:38 AM PDT by COBOL2Java
We have lost sight of what the meaning of the word “exception” means.
When I see a list of “exceptions”, it irritates me. That is a rule established that modifies an existing rule.
When I see or hear someone say “no exceptions”, it likewise irritates me as the whole point of an “exception” occurs through an unforeseen event that creates an exceptional occurrence.
This seems to be a perfect example on a time when an exception should have been made.
One hopes his classmate recognize this as government over-reach masquerading as zero tolerance.
It is the same type of over-reach that South Carolina "officials" demonstrate when they disallow reciprocity to other states gun permits. Why doesn't SC refuse to recognize out-of-state driver licenses as easily as the 2d A?
No, I have to disagree. For the kid to participate in a real sport, with difficult training ... AFTER HAVING BEAT CANCER .... shows true grit. Having been in a somewhat similar situation myself, the goal of joining a sports team might have been one of the things that kept him going during the darkest of his days fighting the disease.
Sports (done correctly) are good and important for body, mind, and the building of character. Don't discount them.
You naysayers, READ THE ABOVE. : "They could have let him walk with his cap & gown and presented him an unsigned or blank diploma. Wouldn’t be a first.
It happens all the time. This young man showed extraordinary commitment and work - thru' debilitating circumstances not of his making... He deserved to graduate with HIS class...not next years - or being made to put everything on hold for another year.
So take your self-righteousness and stuff it...
There have been many kids that got a blank diploma at graduation because they had to go to summer school to pass the class or classes they flunked. They participated with their class. His was a case that could have easily been treated the same. They could have mentioned as they handed him the blank diploma that he would actually be finishing his remaining requirements for graduation that fall. Everyone in the audience would have understood. Class association is very important. Those are your friends and fellow travelers.
Hey, he’s a white guy. No punishment is too great.
I’m as tough as they come when abiding by the rules is involved.But this kid shouldn’t have been excluded under these circumstances.No way!
The Harm is precedent
Many lack the credits to graduate on time
Those here that would break the rules are probably hillary supporters
So leukemia is nothing more than a "slippery slope" to you? Do let us know when you...your spouse...your child...or your grandchild develops leukemia and we just might play the world's smallest violin for you/him/her.
That’s f*cking disgusting. Let him walk, hand him a blank diploma, then quietly mail the real one upon completion. He’s short of credits because he was busy TRYING NOT TO DIE month after month. May they be booed and jeered every time they stick their noses outside.
I might agree with you if he’s wasn’t trying so hard.....
Back in 1990, I was 4 credits short when I entered the senior year in college. I took only one class, once a week, for the entire two semesters. Slight annoyance for me, but I never considered making a stink about it. I don’t think it was the norm back then.
Congrats to the young man for overcoming cancer. That in itself is reward enough.
Well aren’t you special.
Again he didn't ask to graduate early he asked to walk with and sit with his class AFTER he missed school due to Cancer. Years ago locally our school allowed a young man who had been in a car accident and nearly died to walk (with much help) with his class even though he did not finish his school work in time to graduate. He finished it in Summer school and got his diploma. He walked with his class was brought up on stage as an example of someone who would not quit and kept right on with his dreams. And we've never had drama once since then over allowing someone who just didn't get enough credits to wish to walk with their class.
But then around here there is enough people of character in charge that would not allow stupid crap like that. We even still say the pledge of allegiance and have a prayer at school functions. Sad that you live with people of such low character that they can't run things properly.
The Rules Are The Rules!
Besides, he might outshine someone protege. I’m guessing that’s the rest of the story.
This is a good lesson to teach everyone that pricks and morons have great power in this world.....Sorry. This is a great lesson to teach everyone that rules, laws, standards of decency and the ability to get over yourself is paramount. Would you allow a Ranger candidate who can’t hike, run and carry a 100 lb. pack because he was unable to graduate? Graduate a Seal who can’t swim fifteen miles because he has asthma?
The high school I graduated from allowed those graduating in December to walk in the previous June. It was common.
The school would have for privileged liberals.
On the other hand...the picture shows him walking, as part of the overall ceremony, but not doing the cap and gown part - so is he being left out of anything but the part he doesn’t actually qualify for? Looks like he is being separately recognized.
Sounds like whining over minutiae. Perhaps not, if they normally allow almost-graduates to ‘graduate’...but I’ve only seen people compare with what might have been done within alternate traditions.
If he were any minority, we would not be reading this story; he would be participating fully, maybe, as another poster said, as valedictorian.
But I am deep down very glad that this kid is taking up the mantle of being a white male in a society that cuts white males no slack at all.
It's good for us; it makes us stronger than any other group.
It is good practice for him for when he is middle aged and has to pay triple for everything, and be taxed at the highest rate, only to watch dozens of whiny minority families all around him get born and buried for free, pay no taxes generation after generation, get promoted undeservedly via affirmative action, get preference for everything, get free housing, food, college, health care, cell phones, and get praise that ought to go to him and his kids. Welcome to postmodern America.
White males holding society together in the USA. It's always been that way.
Way to go kid, take your medicine.
By the time the next graduation rolls around you will be sickened to be present among the loser faculty and administration who will pretend to honor you, but really can not.... They have no right to honor you.
Hope you blow it off.
Have your own kids get their high school diplomas online, which they should be able to do by age 14. Your kids should not have to breathe the stink of that high school in order to be educated and go on to college, and beyond, to live great lives.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.