Good points about the Five. None seem to be traditional pro-life, pro-traditional marriage conservatives. Gutfeld, although a gifted comic, is an atheist and uses crude humor.
The FIVE current lineup as I see it:
Dana Perino - Never Trumper, Bushy likely voted for Hillary
Jesse Waters - Pro Trump, might be a republican, family is very liberal
Greg Gutfield - Libertarian, some conservative views, but liberal at heart, likely voted for Hillary
Juan Williams, Flaming Liberal democrat of course voted multiple times for Hillary
Jedediah Bila - Plays a conservative not sure it is real, says she is a Trump fan