Posted on 10/13/2023 6:44:02 AM PDT by Cronos
According to the prosecution, Nikita Zhuravel, nineteen, a resident of Volgograd, set fire to the Quran in front of the city’s Cathedral Mosque. Zhuravel filmed the process, too. The man was arrested in May 2023 and charged with, among other things, “offending the religious feelings of believers.”
The defendant did not deny guilt and, in the strangest of explanations, pointed out that Ukrainian special services contacted him and asked him to do what he did in exchange for 10,000 rubles (about $100).
Despite this set up, this is not a story of freedom of expression clashing with religious sensibilities. This is a story of the use of law for political purposes. The main characters in this play, apart from the young and clueless Zhuravel, are the Kremlin administration, the federal law enforcement agencies, and the leadership of the Chechen republic, headed by one of Putin’s most important allies, Ramzan Kadyrov.
Zhuravel did not deny guilt, expressed remorse and, under Russian law, faced relatively light misdemeanor (not felony) charges. Knowing full well that anyone in Zhuravel’s position would be treated most harshly in one of Russia’s majority Muslim regions, the federal investigative body did just that: it sent Zhuravel to Chechnya. The Russian Investigative Committee stated that the reason for transferring the case to another region was “many grounds, in particular, numerous appeals from residents of the Chechen Republic with a request to recognize them as victims.”
Several lawyers, including the author of this piece, believe that transferring the case grossly violated the criminal procedure rules since “requests by residents” cannot serve as grounds for such a transfer. The voluntary and illegal transfer of the case to another region was only the beginning of blatant law violations. These violations clearly and unambiguously show how the law works (or, rather, does not work) in Russia.
On August 16, Nikita Zhuravel filed a claim with the Russian Commissioner for Human Rights, accusing the son of the Chechen governor, fifteen-year-old Adam Kadyrov, of beating him in the detention center. Earlier, Kadyrov Jr. was in the media spotlight when he and his brothers delivered to Chechnya three prisoners of war who had been captured during the war in Ukraine—“as a gift,” one of the sons explained to his father.
Human Rights Ombudsman Tatiana Moskalkova asked her Chechen counterpart, Mansur Soltaev, to check on the claim. Soltaev promised to do so but has not reported the results since then. Human rights activists intervened and appealed to the authorities, but to no avail.
Few doubted the veracity of Zhuravel’s words. In fact, top Chechen officials were not shy to admit the beating. Magomed Daudov, chairman of the Chechen parliament, actually praised the governor’s son: “I am absolutely sure that Adam acted like a true Muslim, a patriot of his country and a real Chechen!” Adam Delimkhanov, a State Duma member from Chechnya, said the following: “Adam did a very humane thing by letting him [Zhuravel] live.”
On such occasions, law enforcement agencies are obliged to investigate, but they did not. The investigation of the video about the burning of the Koran was carried out immediately. However, no law enforcement agency is interested in the apparent battery inside the pre-trial detention center.
On September 25, 2023, Chechen governor Ramzan Kadyrov himself posted a video of the beating on his Telegram channel. “He beat him and did the right thing,” the governor commented on the video, and noted that he was proud of his son. Adam Kadyrov commented on the incident on his Instagram account: “You can gossip, hate, envy and discuss me. But we both realize that when we meet, you will smile at me nicely.”
A little more than a week has passed since the video was published, but there is no sign of any investigation by Russian law enforcement agencies. Presidential spokesman Dmitry Peskov refused to comment on the issue. “I do not want to,” Peskov “explained.” After the video appeared in the public domain, President Putin held a meeting with the governor of Chechnya. The issue was not raised at that time.
In general, complaints about batteries and torture in places of detention appear constantly in Russia. As a rule, only the publication of video evidence prompts the start of at least some investigation, which has a slight chance of ending with a punishment. Nevertheless, it did not happen in this case, when the video was intentionally published to show the nature of power in Chechnya and the place of local authorities in their relations with the federal government.
As a rule, the government uses the law selectively to punish perceived enemies or to protect loyalists. In this case, the government achieves both purposes. The state punishes Zhuravel through the ordinary criminal justice process and law violations, transferring the case to a region where the alleged criminal will be treated more harshly. The same approach protects those whom the government wants to protect: the governor’s son, the governor himself, and the detention center staff.
Officials in Chechnya support the violation of the law, while the federal authorities remain silent. In the same way, the federal authorities kept silent while investigating the murder of the Russian opposition leader Boris Nemtsov in 2015. When suspicions arose that the murder had been organized from Chechnya, the investigators simply did not pursue the lead.
Russia has been living under conditions of selective law enforcement for many years. It is constantly corroding the country’s legal system and reducing the already low level of trust in institutions. Such selective enforcement has already evolved from individual cases to categories. For example, cases in Chechnya have their own rules for when and how the law is applied.
A similar situation has developed with criminal cases related to discrediting the army and anti-war statements. Such continuous selective enforcement leads to the idea that Russia is now nothing more than a failed state in which the law’s mass operation depends on specific individuals’ wishes. It leads to a situation in which the state loses its ability to govern and maintain its legal sovereignty.
19-year-old Nikita Zhuravel burned Koran in Volgograd in May 2023.
He was transferred to Chechnya penitentiary system for trial on request of Ramzan Kadyrov, who insisted that all Chechens are victims of Zhuravel, so he must be prosecuted in Chechnya.
ven Kremlin’s mouthpiece Dmitry Peskov had to comment.
“I’m saying straight away that I will not comment on the story with Kadyrov’s son,” proclaimed Peskov at a briefing.
“Why won’t you?” a journalist probed.
“Don’t want to,” Peskov replied.
That poor young man will not get out of there alive.................................
They’re just trying to avoid a bigger problem. Just look at the riots in Indonesia when the cartoons in Paris were printed making fun of Mohammed.
It’s called defusing the situation. Doesn’t matter who is getting screwed.
Anyone remember the church fella here(NC?) was going to do a public burning? Some DC General called him and implored him not to do it. If the SHTF in the form of another 911 I’m sure it will happen.
A functioning state holds the only license to commit violence against its citizens. Delegating this license is an astonishing voluntary loss of that authority. It seems symptomatic of the collapse of the power of the state. So, the question is how will the other Russian citizens view this? I’m thinking they’ll view it negatively. While this is not in itself significant, it’s like how a divorce happens. A divorce is not usually from one incident. It’s from many smaller divorcements. Then, suddenly, they all accumulate and one party or the other is simply finished with the relationship.
Cronos, with the Ukraine in free fall, maybe this is the right war for you to join?
I’m thinking the kid would get the equivalent punishment pretty much anywhere in Western Europe these days.
“Cronos, with the Ukraine in free fall, maybe this is the right war for you to join?”
What is this ‘Ukraine’ that I see once in a great while here? Perhaps a construction equipment rental company?
My guess is that he will be convicted and then admitted into an amnesty program for serving in Ukraine as cannon fodder.
I’m old enough to remember when it was really bad news to commit “crimes” against the Democrat Party in the Democrat/Uniparty stronghold of Washington DC...
Unfortunately.
“Mum’s the word.”
LOL - if this is the best he can do to attack Putin today, I guess he doesn’t have much material to work with.
“Unfortunately.”
Yep, it should have never gotten this far. Europe, at least Western Europe, is going full Fascist, maybe to the point of making Hitler squirm in his grave. And unless we’re lucky, we’ll be joining them, and it will be far worse than even Europe.
Just because an fbi AGENT accompanied the terrorists, encouraged them and was, probably, going to film the attack, you think.../sarc
From the article, “Russia has been living under conditions of selective law enforcement for many years.”
Is the author unaware of what has been happening to President Trump? And what about you Cronos?
Russia enforcing sharia law. Just another example of how they are the saviors of Christendom, I guess.
But all the Putin Fanbois on FR assure me that Putin is the savior of Western Civilization, and here he is pandering to the Islamists.
Why, its almost as if Putin were just a cynical KGB thug at heart, who doesn't really believe in anything, except his will to power, and Russian Conquest. /sarcasm
And at least Kadyrov gets a cash subsidy, and now a Russian to abuse, in return for his support of Putin. Putin Fanbois sell their souls for illusions.
All of that and Putin must kiss his muzzies because he is lacking fresh conscripts to fuel his war.
Too many funerals in the Moscow/Petersburg area is a no-go for Putin. They are already low on workers and the optics are to be avoided.
Bonus points for Putin for keeping the pur sang Russians warm and safe.
The hand you cannot bite, you must kiss.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.