Skip to comments.How Forums Are Being Taken Over By Pro-Arab Groups, Who Flood The Forums With Hate Propaganda
Posted on 06/05/2002 3:36:46 AM PDT by the_second_moon
PALO ALTO When he discovered anti-Israeli propaganda in an Internet site devoted to baking bread, Doron Gal was dumfounded. It would seem that Islamic and anti-Israeli forces discovered the world wide web long before Israelis did, and they are running a well-oiled machine to create public opinion in cyberspace. For such purposes, a site on making cookies is just as good as a political vehicle.
Asked why such groups infiltrate non-political sites, Gal, a doctor in geophysics and a co-founder of the startup DigiGroups, explains that like movie stars bad publicity is better than no publicity at all. Even if other participants in the forum ask them to change the subject, it takes time until their claims drop to the bottom of the screen. Meanwhile, people see them and take in the message.
"They have set criteria by which to choose sites," Gal says: sites that can boast heavy surfer traffic, or that are popular with younger people, because the young tend to be more radical. And, of course, sites devoted to political debate.
Moreover, they have clever ways to promote their agenda. For instance, the writer could claim that he cant concentrate on baking bread because his uncle in Bethlehem was just killed by Israelis. That attracts attention.
Only after Gal had visited several sites over several days did he cotton on. It can't be that every time somebody starts to break the eggs into his bread dough in Palestine, his uncle gets killed. Something methodical was going on. The following sentence, after mentioning the uncle's demise, would take a more militant tone, for instance a description of how Israelis murder babies and sell their organs.
The hate-drenched lies appear in thousands of sites. Googling for "intifada" leads to some 50 pro-Palestinian sites, and barely two or three pro-Israeli ones. That is because Google's technology leads to the most popular sites. Popularity is measured, in part, by the number of links to the site on Internet. The Palestinian sites link to one another, and Google identifies them as outstandingly popular.
Methodology of disseminating hate
The Islamicist extremists are cunning in their exploitation of the electronic media, , Gal admits. One method is for several activists to log on to a forum or chat room together, and discourse between them. One raises the claim about Israelis selling body parts of murdered Palestinians. When the argument turns tense, another comes in ostensibly holding more moderate views making the other chatters feel he is objective.
"It is very hard for a private individual to handle this kind of propaganda on the Internet," Gal says. If the situation is to be amended, it has to be handled in an organized fashion.
"When I realized how serious the situation is, given my experience in Internet communities (through his startup DigiGroups), I decided I want to undertake the mission. I don't see myself as a propagandist and don't see it as a career. But I know what has to be done and how to return war."
Gal, 37, is at a good time in his life to undertake the job. His startup was sold in a stock swap. Given the tough market he'd be better off looking for a new job right away, but as an Israeli who cares he feels compelled to tackle this mission first.
Doron Gal founded digiGroups in 1999 together with Uri Sarid and Eran Liron. The company created a web-based platform for building business communities. Gal says he was less attracted by the hope of making millions, and more by the opportunity to be at the fore-front of technological advance, and to create something big of use to people. Back then, he says wryly, naivete was okay. The three ex-academicians thought they were joining a brand new world mistakenly, of course.
Anyway, they managed to raise $14 million for their startup, settled for unusually low salaries (for that time) and settled down to work very, very hard. At its peak the company boasted 40 employees, but it targeted vertical marketplaces, which turned out to be a bad move. As its market dried up, the company started to seek new angles, Gal tells.
"It isn't easy to take a glove and find it a new hand," he says. The company adapted its product to big enterprises. But the sector, and Internet, were at a nadir. The venture capital funds figured it would take ages to return their investment, and when digiGroups got a takeover offer they pushed, and it bit. Despite prior understandings, the buyer, Noosh, cut the staff in half and Gal too found himself on the sidewalk, holding a block of Noosh shares, living in an expensive neighborhood with his wife Michal and two kids, and with no salary.
Seduced by Internet propaganda
It may not have gone public, but digiGroups brought Doron Gal to the world of Internet communities.
"I noticed that several big forums in which hundreds of thousands of people participate are being taken over by anti-Israeli and pro-Arab groups, who flood the forums with hate propaganda," Gal says. "If you consider that in the U.S. alone, 134 million people are linked to Internet, and half of them actively participate in all kinds of groups, you see that the impact of such propaganda can be enormous."
"The deeper I probed, the graver the things I uncovered," he continues. "A typical story might run like this.
'Here's proof there never were gas chambers (in the Holocaust the writer links to several sites). 'It's a bunch of Jewish lies to divert attention from their massacres of Palestinians.' (More links.) 'The Jews aren't strategic allies. All the States needs is oil, but it supports the Jews because they control Congress and the media. (More links to prove his case.)
"I sat down to reply at length, to refute his case," Gal says. "I showed that the links were misleading. In retrospect, I realize I was amateurish. When you encounter such claims for the first time, it takes ages to prove they're fatuous. Meanwhile tons of people have seem them and the debate has changed subject. The key is that the answer has to come fast.
"The more experience I gained, the more I understood the need for fast, catchy answers. It isn't just a war over opinions, it's a propaganda war. Sometimes the answer needs to be clear and informative, sometimes just a disparaging comment like 'Don't you get tired of writing that crap? Go fly a plane into a skyscraper.'
"It's a war, and we're coming to it too little, too late. The assumption is that they have hundreds of thousands of activists and about 10 to 20 times as many inactive supporters, meaning, millions. They are well organized, they have access to easy, convenient-to-use information, and they are trying to delegitimize Israel by rewriting the history of the Arab-Israeli conflict.
Results in half a year
"The war isn't lost," Doron Gal declares. There are pro-Israeli groups that produce solid information, but their efforts are too scattered and purely pathetic compared with the smooth operation of the anti-Israeli groups.
DigiGroups taught Gal the power of Internet communities, in which leaders wield tremendous clout. "I believe we can round up several hundred volunteers, including Israelis with good command of English. Our purpose is to support our activists, and organize material and technology allowing efficient use of Internet for them." The idea would be to insert replies within seconds to hate-propaganda on websites.
Gal believes that organizing and training people will take a few months. Results should become evident within half a year. He needs $580,000 to make it happen, a fraction of the cost of big ad campaigns.
"As a family man and father to two children, I should have started looking for a job right away," he admits. "My wife Michal hates uncertainty." But a cause is a cause and Gal is confident the money for the anti-anti-Israel campaign can be found, enabling him to devote all his attention to the project.
And if it can't? He'll have to take a day job, and devote his evenings, weekends and holidays to the cause. "It may not be efficient," he realizes, "but I'd rather fight the war with one hand tied behind my back, than not fight at all."
Flee Pallies! Flee! I'm sure the Israelis wouldn't mind if you actually did.
In light of that I've personally decided to start calling those towns and cities "tramp camps", since the Pallies want to tramp on the Israelis and drive them into the sea.
tramp: to tread on forcibly and repeatedly
I didn't want to call them squatter camps or hobo camps as it denigrates hobos and squatters.
Have I shown my bias? Oops!
Kill all the islamic terrorists first. Then we can consider Isreal. Islamic terrorists are not just after Jews, but Christians and Americans, too--they've said so at every opportunity. As a Christian and an American, fundy islamists made ME an enemy.
Take YOUR venom elsewhere!
Top Saudi imam sees conspiracy
LONDON - Saudi Arabia's top Muslim cleric has called on the Islamic world to unite against a worldwide conspiracy of Hindus, Christians, Jews and secularists threatening Islamic moral values.
I guess Christians and Jews weren't enough of an enemy for this guy.
Sounds to me like this clown is just looking for an excuse to sit home all day and post to the internet forums and get paid for it at the same time. Besides, he's got things backward. Anyone who has spent time on internet forums knows its the pro-Zionist folks who spew the most propaganda and work hardest to censor the views of those they disagree with.
There are peaceful Muslims, but they are unfortunately not the ones controlling the influential institutions of Islamic thought.
Sounds to me like you prefer censorship over debate.
If you don't know why the snake is there, don't be surprised if you find another tomorrow night, and the night after that. Eventually one will get you.
The difference between the two sides lies in the mindless support that the Zionists receiveThat, and the Jews not strapping bombs on themselves, women, and children in order to murder innocent bystanders.
Gee, I don't know why we bash Isamists. Just because Christians are killed in many Islamic countries, and Islam is behind most terroristic attacks against Americans, and Islamic countries constantly denounce the western way of life, and Islamic countries are pretty clear on their desire to wipe Jews out. I just don't understand.......
Flying airliners into buildings is NOT debate. Blowing up buses, pizza parlors, supermarkets, and nurseries is NOT debate. Your inability to comprehend these points does NOT obligate me to give you and respect.
Maybe I should expand my target set. The non-peaceful Muslims need to go away--along with those who support them. And this needs to happen by any means necessary.
Neither is Zionist propaganda debate.
It is so un-PC to criticize Israel.True. Even someone who supports Israel can be accused of being a PLO supporter or even "anti-semetic" if they criticize the actions of the current Israeli government or :gasp: claim that Israel can't always be trusted.
It reminds me of Roger Clinton saying that people who criticized his brother were committing treason. It's the purest form of bullmodell.
LOL!! Where have you been for the last six months!!! It is now very chic for the looniest of the left to unabashedly slam Israel. Everyone wants to get in on the act. From whacked out Berkeley students to Hollywood headcases, no Palestinian terrorists is too rough for them to consider warm and cuddly!!
He did, but he only has so much brain power in reserve. After posting his idiotic comments there wasn't enough left over to move his body around. All that hand-eye coordination was too much.
Hence he's immobilized right now, forced to stare at his screen while we make fun of him.
Hey, watch it, you Palestinion propagandist. (/sarcasm)
I wasn't going to jump in on this, but I believe that you were the first one to use a perjorative ("mindless") with respect to supporters of the position opposite yours. I think you fired the first salvo, and got the responses you deserved. Next time, avoid the ad hominems.
Don't you have a suicide bombing appointment? 7 posted on 6/5/02 5:00 AM Pacific by Poohbah
Thank you. You just proved the point of this article with your latest burst of verbal flatulence. 14 posted on 6/5/02 5:14 AM Pacific by Poohbah
Which hardly supports the "refugee" status, but tramp will do. 15 posted on 6/5/02 5:15 AM Pacific by wita
BTW, you're doing a FINE job of convincing me that any world without Islam is a better place than the present world. 20 posted on 6/5/02 5:33 AM Pacific by Poohbah
Sounds to me like you do not understand what I was talking about, and merely opened your mouth to let your ignorance into the public domain. 32 posted on 6/5/02 6:00 AM Pacific by Poohbah
He did, but he only has so much brain power in reserve. After posting his idiotic comments there wasn't enough left over to move his body around.38 posted on 6/5/02 6:10 AM Pacific by AAABEST
What side is it again that uses ad hominum arguments?
Gee, let's review those morals, shall we?
Brainwashing their own children form birth.
So called leaders duping ignorant followers into "martyrdom" while they sit back and reap the benefits.
Keeping your women non-sentient.
Blowing up innocent people, including innocnet children, and other Arabs (Allan ain't going to like that, Muhammed!!).
Keeping your people uneducated and in abject poverty for the sole purpose of generating more "martyrs"
Believing that "discussion" consisits of "This is my position (as beaten into me since birth) on everything. If you disagree, you are an infidel and must immediately die." Yeah, really civilized!
Purposely misinterpreting the Qur'an to promote your twisted philosophies.
Raising a population of men so sexually frustrated, that the simple glimpse of a woman's ankle sends them into a sexual frenzy (and then condemn and stone to death the woman that you attack, or have an affair with, or have any contact with when not in the presence of a close male relative).
And the list goes on.
Pardon me for laughing.
Isreal is showing considerably more restraint than I would in the identical situation.
The "mindless" comment was in post #3, before all the otheres. Not defending ad hominem in general, but LDD was first out of the box, then complains when it is served right back. If he wants to challenge support for Israel, let him do so with facts rather than initiating with a rant about the "mindlessness" of those who disagree. Else, he shouldn't complain that it gets served right back at him.
Looks to me as if FReepers could make this happen sooner & cheaper. MOST Freepers, anyway. It appears to me that the site has been infiltrated by the sort of groups Gal was referring to.
I think you are confusing it with the truth.
Lion Den Dan's comment about 'mindless support', whether you agree or disagree with it, was not ad hominem. It was an assertion, not a personal attack. Unfortunately, many of the responses he received were hateful personal attacks. We can judge who is flooding this forum with hate propaganda. It isn't pro-Arab groups.
This month's axe, www.freerepublic.com, was recommended by a reader who says he was angered by the anti-Palestinian, anti-Muslim posts he saw frequently appearing on the site. After frequent objections, he himself was banned from it...please register and post , the source of many summer, 2001 pro Palestinian and anti-Israel freepers.