To: Doctor Stochastic
Perhaps you could post where the the lack of amino acids in the Murchison meteorite was published. A link to a refereed journal article would be sufficient. No need to waste time looking. If they had been found in a meteorite, we would not still be looking for amino acids in space. BTW - this guy was already disproven once by his fellow scientists. This new study has not been examined yet. It is worthless until it is. However, like the meteorites, I am sure it will be disproven quietly.
99 posted on
07/23/2002 8:05:33 PM PDT by
gore3000
To: gore3000
Then, lacking evidence, why did you claim that there were no amino acide in the Murchison meteorite? Do you usually make claims without such evidence? If you are unwilling to back your claims, why should anyone pay attention to your wildly elliptical posts?
Just because one finds amino acids in a meteorite, why do you believe that that precludes one from looking other places?
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson