Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

So We Fight ^ | 9/11/02 | George Will

Posted on 09/11/2002 4:03:27 PM PDT by johnb838

WASHINGTON--In our mind's eye we see them, the police and firefighters, the passengers of United Flight 93 and all the others who disappeared behaving nobly. The mind's eye holds a mixture of emotions, including anger, directed at primitive enemies from abroad, and at the faux sophistication of some homegrown thinking.

The thinking is as contemptible as, and more dangerous than, any foreign enemy, now or ever, because its agenda is to discredit ideas that make nobility intelligible and hence heroism possible. Last Sept. 11 was, among other things, the Great Refutation. And perhaps a catalyst of a sustained restoration.

Ideas have consequences--indeed, only ideas have large and lasting consequences--so history is, at bottom, the history of mind. The acts of war a year ago made up our nation's mind, as one restores order to an unmade bed. We made up our mind to fight, of course, but also to become virtuously intolerant of a certain kind of nonsense, including the notion that tolerance is everything because everything else is nothing--nothing but opinion or chimera.

The postmodern plague of quotation marks--the punctuation of disparagement that labels as superstitions ``virtue'' and ``heroism'' and most of the other things that make life worth living--was erased by men running into burning buildings, men who had not been disabled by today's higher learning. The quotation marks remaining after the Great Refutation surround two words: ``Let's roll!''

The cultural relativism that gives rise to the fetish of multiculturalism--``It is mere ethnocentric arrogance to say one culture is superior to any other''--was incinerated by burning jet fuel. Reductionism--the realism of people blind to reality--holds that individuals are just soups of chemical reactions, that all motives are banal and tawdry, that the best biographies are pathographies, piercing the veil of human greatness to reveal grounds for diminishment. Thus is mind, and hence valor, drained from history.

Which licenses the envy of the untalented, giving rise to what has been called the revenge of failure: Those who cannot paint destroy the canons of painting, those who cannot write reject canonical literature. One conclusion compelled by this is that progress is impossible, indeed meaningless--a conclusion from which many ``progressives'' flinch.

The blowsy handmaiden of all this is the notion that everything can be understood as an emanation of this or that culture, no one of which is superior to any other, and therefore to understand is to forgive. But to understand our enemies is to know they must be smashed.

Susceptibility to feelings of civic guilt and a tendency to social hypochondria are two generally healthy American attributes traceable to the Republic's founding--to living in the long shadow cast by the great men whose rhetoric and documents gave vitality to great principles. So last Sept. 11, there was an American reflex to ask, self-accusingly: ``What did we do?''

The reflex was wrong. Our enemies attacked us not for what we have done but for what we (BEG ITAL)are. And because of the attacks, we are even more intensely what we are, a nation defined by our (BEG ITAL)unum, not our (BEG ITAL)pluribus. The nation's great seal, proclaiming (BEG ITAL)e pluribus unum, was adopted in 1782, five years before the Constitution was written, and six years after the Declaration of Independence, with its declaration of equality of rights, made us, as Lincoln was to say at Gettysburg, a nation dedicated to a proposition.

The proposition, and all it entails, enrages, to the point of derangement, our enemies. So we fight.

Emerson, who spent much time around high-minded abolitionists who were as ardent for avoiding war as they were for ending slavery, probably startled, even scandalized many readers when he wrote that war can ``educate the senses, call into action the will, and perfect the physical constitution." Hence his exclamation at the outbreak of the Civil War: ``Ah! sometimes gunpowder smells good."

The Civil War, and with it the right of some human beings to own others, might have had a different end if penicillin had been available 80 years earlier. If, that is, Stonewall Jackson, wounded at Chancellorsville in May 1863, had survived infection and been at Gettysburg in July.

Sometimes gunpowder does smell good because civilization--especially the highest, ours--is not inevitable. So we fight.

TOPICS: Editorial
This is maybe the best thing I've ever read by George Will.
1 posted on 09/11/2002 4:03:27 PM PDT by johnb838
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: johnb838
That's my opinion as well.

2 posted on 09/11/2002 4:58:11 PM PDT by Coeur de Lion
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: johnb838
3 posted on 09/11/2002 5:02:18 PM PDT by tet68
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: johnb838
4 posted on 09/11/2002 5:02:29 PM PDT by Brett66
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: johnb838
He writes a lot of good stuff. Good post, John.
5 posted on 09/11/2002 5:07:35 PM PDT by johniegrad
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: johnb838
"We made up our mind to fight..."

Afghanistan aside, all we have made our mind up to do is to talk, and talk, and talk.

If I were President, I would have celebrated the anniversary of the 11th by firing cruise missles at various Iraqi and other Muslim targets with a note attached: Happy Anniversary Assholes.

If Bush had done this today, the public would demand that the Constitution be ammended to allow him a third and fourth term.

But we're still talkin'.

6 posted on 09/11/2002 7:00:12 PM PDT by wcbtinman
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: wcbtinman
I do agree with you. All day, I was hoping that President Bush would make this little speech:

"It has taken us a year for us to positively identify those resonsible for the attack upon America last year. While I am talking to you, multiple ICMB missiles have been launched and will impact their designated targets within 20 minutes."

But alas, we all knew this would never happen. Unfortunatly, many American lives will be lost as a result.

7 posted on 09/11/2002 7:08:19 PM PDT by Hunble
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

To: johnb838
I agree.

I wish I were as confident as he is, though, about how "the people" look at the rest of the world.

Watching those nauseating tributes to the "tragedy" of 9/11/01 yesterday, I was struck instead about how complacent we are in our blindness.

8 posted on 09/12/2002 7:06:46 AM PDT by Illbay
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson