Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

A Reasoned and Articulate View of Islam
Q-News ^ | Hamza Yusuf

Posted on 09/14/2002 8:50:07 AM PDT by meia

This article first appeared in Q-News, the Muslim magazine,

On September 11th our lives changed forever. We witnessed an act of aggression that in many ways does not have a parallel in past or present times. There are several elements that make this act unique, from the use of civilian planes as weapons of mass destruction to the attack on the most widely recognised skyscrapers in the world. Nor have we ever witnessed the terrible indictment of Islam as having a part to play in such a heinous crime, writes Hamza Yusuf.


Muslims were seen rejoicing in some parts of the world in a display of what can only be called shamaatatul 'aadai', which is rejoicing at the calamities of ones’ enemies. This is something explicitly prohibited in Islam and was never practiced by the Prophet of Mercy, upon him be prayers and peace. We have seen images since of American flags burning to further arouse the wrath of a nation filled with grief, confusion and anger. Again, Islam prohibits the burning of flags according to the explicit verse, “Do not curse [the idols] of those who call on other than Allah, thus causing them to curse Allah out of animosity [toward you] and without knowledge.” This verse prohibits even the cursing of false gods because of the consequences.  We have also seen image after image of Muslims with beards and turbans, who by all outward means look religious and pious - but are they really?

Unfortunately, the West does not know what every Muslim scholar knows; that the worst enemies of Islam are from within. The worst of these are the khawaarij who delude others by the deeply dyed religious exterior that they project. The Prophet, peace be upon him, said about them, “When you see them pray you will consider your own prayers insignificant. They recite the Quran but it does not exceed the limits of their throat.”  In other words, they don’t understand the true meanings. The outward religious appearance and character of the khawaarij deluded thousands in the past, and continues to delude people today. The Muslims should be aware that despite the khawaarij adherence to certain aspects of Islam, they are extremists of the worst type. 

Our Prophet said, peace be upon him, “Beware of extremism in your religion.”  Islam is the middle way between excess and neglect. Zealots are a plague upon religion. These extremists come in two types. The first is a reactionary extremist who falls far right of a centre-point. Reactionary extremists do not want any pluralism; they view the world in melodramatic, black and white, good and evil terms. They are good and anyone who opposes them is evil. From among the Muslims these are people who ‘excommunicate’ any Muslim who fails to share their interpretations of the Quran. They use takfir and character assassination as a tool for marginalising any criticism directed at them. They are used often by the Western media in order to scare simple people and cause them to believe that Muslims are insane. Unfortunately, our communities provide them with much fuel to fire their incendiary flames. 

The second group are radical extremists, who while they are almost identical with the former group, differ in that they will use violence to further their cause. They are actually worse than the first. They believe like every nefarious secret society before them that ‘the end justifies the means.’ They see any act as acceptable if it will further their ‘cause.’ This is blatantly anti-Islamic for a number of reasons.

Firstly, Islam’s means must reflect its noble ends. Any means that does not embody the core truths and ethics of Islam is not from Islam and thus denounced as aberration. Secondly, Islam is not a secret society of conspirators who no one knows what they are planning. Islam declares openly its aims and objectives and these are recognised by good people everywhere as pure and congruent with their own wisdom and traditions. In the case of many of these extremists even the non-Muslims recognise that no religion of any weight could sanction the taking of innocent lives. The Quran says that the Torah and the Gospel have guidance and light and that the Quran came to fulfil these prior dispensations. Good Christians and Jews who believe in God and live ethically upright lives have no frame of reference for such acts, so how could these acts be from Islam, which confirms what has come before it? 

Thirdly, they are invariably people who have never taken a true spiritual path to God and nor have they studied the humanities. I can almost guarantee that you will not find a scholar of poetry among the whole vile lot of these people. They have no true knowledge of Arabian culture, which is centred in the idea of futuwwa; a word akin to the western word chivalry. The terrorists posing as journalists who killed Ahmad Shah Masuud were cowards of the worst type. Killing themselves was not bravery but stupidity, but killing one’s enemy in such a way is the worst form of treachery and the Arabs have many poems denouncing such type of people. 

Our real situation is this: we Muslims have lost theologically sound understanding of our teaching. Islam has been hijacked by a discourse of anger and the rhetoric of rage. We have allowed for too long our mimbars to become bully pulpits in which people with often recognisable psychopathology use anger - a very powerful emotion - to rile Muslims up, only to leave them feeling bitter and spiteful towards people who in the most part are completely unaware of the conditions in the Muslim world, or the oppressive assaults of some Western countries on Muslim peoples. We have lost our bearings because we have lost our theology. We have almost no theologians in the entire Muslim world. The study of kalaam, once the hallmark of our intellectual tradition, has been reduced to memorizing 144 lines of al-Jawhara and a good commentary to study it, at best.

The reality is we are an Umma that no longer realises that Allah is the power behind all power; that it is Allah who subjugates one people to another; that He gives dominion to whom He pleases and He takes it away from whom He pleases. Our understanding of tawhid has fallen into such disarray that we can no longer introspect when afflictions befall us and then wonder in amazement at why the Americans seem incapable of introspection. Indeed, I personally attended a memorial service in San Francisco with over 30,000 people and the Reverend Amos Brown said in no uncertain terms that America must ask herself what she has done either wittingly or unwittingly to incur the wrath and hate of people around the world. Muslims on the other hand, generally prefer to attack the West as the sole reason for their problems when the truth is we are bankrupt as a religious community and our spiritual bankruptcy has led to our inability to even deliver the message of Islam to Westerners in a time when they were giving us platforms to do so. 

It is ironic that the Western media while producing many vile programs on Islam has also produced and aired material of the highest quality with a high level of accuracy only to be vilified by Muslims because it was not good enough. Where is our media?  Where are our spokespeople?  Where are our scholars? Where are our literary figures?  The truth is we don’t have any - and so instead of looking inward and asking painful questions such as why we don’t have such things and such people, we take the simple way out by attacking people whom Allah tells us will do mean things, say bad things and plot against us. And always when we are warned we are told to be patient, to work for the good, to trust in Allah, to return to Allah, to implement our deen.

Conspiracy or not, we are to blame for the terrible backlash against Muslims. The simple reason is that when a crazy Christian does something terrible, everyone in the West knows it is the actions of a mad man because they have some knowledge of the core beliefs and ethics of Christianity. When a mad Muslim does something evil or foolish they assume it is from the religion of Islam, not because they hate us but because they have never been told by a Muslim what the teachings of Islam are all about.


TOPICS: Culture/Society; Foreign Affairs; Philosophy
KEYWORDS: christian; islam; muslim; religion
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 81-100101-120121-140141-158 next last
To: AzJP
"Al Capone embraced Catholicism, as he killed."
And was repudiated by the majority of those who call themselves Catholics

"Mr. Clinton embraced Christianity, as he lied to his wife."
And was condemmed by pastors and laymen in pulpits throughout the country.

Now please fill in the blank"

"Muslim fanatics hijacked American airliners and flew them into the WTC and Pentagon"

(fill in blank) ---------------------------

We're waiting . . .

101 posted on 09/14/2002 11:27:36 AM PDT by KeyBored
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 94 | View Replies]

To: inflorida
His argument has run dry and he's just making things up now... typical Muslim apologetics strategy.
102 posted on 09/14/2002 11:28:36 AM PDT by ValerieUSA
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 100 | View Replies]

To: ValerieUSA
I am sorry to be slow to translate, and we are called to the dinner table. I'm amazed that you know that the NYC terrorists used the English phrase "Praise God". I would have ecpected "Inshallah" but if you know of the equivalency to those terrosts of God / Allah, thank you.

Best to you, Ryan

103 posted on 09/14/2002 11:31:47 AM PDT by AzJP
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 96 | View Replies]

To: justjlb
Taqqiah - decieving the infidels.

Anyway the jihadis were told to blend in and enjoy. They were going to paradise for their service to allah anyway.

What steams me is the argument is made that they weren't real muslims because they went to a strip joint, but not because they were coldblooded murdering scums who would've done us all a favor by dribbling down their mama's thighs instead.
104 posted on 09/14/2002 11:32:52 AM PDT by swarthyguy
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 99 | View Replies]

To: ValerieUSA

     (the old heathen says 'hey' ...)

105 posted on 09/14/2002 11:34:22 AM PDT by tomkat
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 102 | View Replies]

To: swarthyguy
precisely. They were REAL muslims all right.
And thanks for the word.
106 posted on 09/14/2002 11:35:35 AM PDT by justjlb
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 104 | View Replies]

To: AzJP
I'm amazed that you know that the NYC terrorists used the English phrase "Praise God".

Huh? They said "Allah Akbar"
You aren't even trying to make sense.

107 posted on 09/14/2002 11:36:33 AM PDT by ValerieUSA
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 103 | View Replies]

To: tomkat
once again, perhaps i should clarify:

if you're sympathetic to the vermin that have attacked us, for whatever reason, you are my enemy.

if i should happen to be close enough to witness an attempted terrorist attack on my nation, i will do my best to eradicate the source of same, by whatever means come to hand.

now, that ought to be fairly clear, oughtn't it ?

Gee, sure sounds like a threat. Should I be scared?

108 posted on 09/14/2002 11:36:53 AM PDT by meia
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 89 | View Replies]

To: meia
It disturbs me greatly when I see "moderate" Muslims attempting to equate OBL with Christians like Falwell, Robertson, and Phelps. Needless to say, the analogy is inaccurate in every conceivable way.
109 posted on 09/14/2002 11:40:50 AM PDT by Mr. Mojo
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: KeyBored
"Can't speak for anyone else, but I for one haven't accused you of fostering hatred or genocide. In fact in my first post to you I thanked you for posting this article"

Meia is having a problem with me. I warned her that her combative style was having the effect of making MORE people honestly want to wipe Islam off the face of the planet, not LESS.

In all my years, I've never seen purposely angering a group of people work as a tool to soften hearts. Additionally, Meia is unable to comprehend that most FReepers don't WANT to kill all Muslims, and we find her posts to be intellectually insulting.

As you can see from Meia's "I don't understand what you mean by that" posts, Meia is either being deliberately and stubbornly obtuse about the damage she's causing, or is just naturally dense.

110 posted on 09/14/2002 11:41:07 AM PDT by cake_crumb
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 87 | View Replies]

To: meia
I think this [the governments of said countries NEED the radicals] is a key to understanding Islam and Muslims.

Yes, but governments don't arise in a vacuum. It is unfortunate but I expect it will take centuries before the culture mellows as it did in the West. In the meantime we will have to protect ourselves in a continuing war of civilization vs. barbarity.

111 posted on 09/14/2002 11:42:02 AM PDT by edsheppa
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 33 | View Replies]

To: meia; AzJP

This photograph was seized from Saudi Arabian fighters captured in Crni Vrh near Teslic, Bosnia. A Muslim solder displays the severed head of Blagoje Blagojevic, a Serb from the village of Jasenovo near Teslic. Friend of yours? A role model or mentor, maybe?

112 posted on 09/14/2002 11:43:11 AM PDT by swarthyguy
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 108 | View Replies]

To: swarthyguy
"Guess they don't understand the impressions they are creating - or they know perfectly well what they are doing."

Yep. A lot of the crap I've been hearing, which also happened to be the same thing, in concentrated form, coming from the family and "friends" of the The Jokers' yesterday, STINKS of a reverse psy-ops project.

The bulk of them, IMO, are ignorant of the impressions they're's committing suicide, without the addded bonus of taking innocent kafir with you can bagging 72 bags of pig...err...virgins.

On the other hand, if they want an excuse for starting an intifada in this country - AND THEY DO WANT INTIFADA HERE - then they're succeeding....until we kill them all.

113 posted on 09/14/2002 11:50:10 AM PDT by cake_crumb
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 77 | View Replies]

To: meia
No, it does not mean that all whites are suspected of being serial killers, but it does mean that if you are looking for a serial killer and you detain 80 year old oriental ladies while ignoring all the white males between 20 and 50 you are a fool. If you are looking for a serial killer in this country you look first at young adult white males and when you are looking for a terrorist you look first at young adult middle eastern males.
114 posted on 09/14/2002 11:51:25 AM PDT by RipSawyer
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 17 | View Replies]

To: meia
Gee, sure sounds like a threat. Should I be scared?

A trifle paranoid, are you? All Tomkat said was that he'd do his best to eradicate the source of a terrorist attack on The United States (should he happen to witness an attempt). How is that a threat to you unless you plan on participating in such a terrorist attack?

Expect a knock on your door soon.

115 posted on 09/14/2002 11:51:50 AM PDT by Mr. Mojo
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 108 | View Replies]

To: cake_crumb
Additionally, Meia is unable to comprehend that most FReepers don't WANT to kill all Muslims, and we find her posts to be intellectually insulting.

Can you point out where I have said that Freepers want to kill all muslims?

116 posted on 09/14/2002 11:52:43 AM PDT by meia
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 110 | View Replies]

To: AzJP
"I'm amazed that you know that the NYC terrorists used the English phrase "Praise God". I would have ecpected "Inshallah" but if you know of the equivalency to those terrosts of God / Allah, thank you. "

IIRC, the phrase used by the hijackers was "Allah Akbar"


Are you a linguist?

117 posted on 09/14/2002 11:56:02 AM PDT by cake_crumb
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 103 | View Replies]

To: meia
only if you side with the terrs, sweetpea ...   

btw, bottom of the sixth, 2 out, nobody on ...



just know you're curious

118 posted on 09/14/2002 11:56:19 AM PDT by tomkat
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 108 | View Replies]

Comment #119 Removed by Moderator

Comment #120 Removed by Moderator

Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 81-100101-120121-140141-158 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson