[chnsmok]

New York is where I'd rather be...

[alley cat]

I get allergic smelling hay!

(Sorry, this thread has deteriorated into silliness and I resisted it for a while but it finally got me.)

[Friend of thunder]

New York is where I'd rather be

I believe it should be “New York is where I'd rather stay” so you can rhyme “I get allergic smelling hay.”

BTW, is there any more information on the original story?