TLB, WW2 has nothing to do with it.
Peaceful American Muslims are prtected by the Constitution. If they aren't hurting anyone then they are fully within their right's to worship whomever they choose.
What you offer as an answer is nothing more than religious oppression, on a massive scale. You want to validate Osama's message and oppress the very people we are supposed to be converting.. in the midst of the freeest nation in the world.
I do not see how your plan would help matters at all. It's based on a paranoid conspiracy theory that could just as easily be leveled at Jews or Christians tomorrow as it can at Peaceful American Muslims today.
I see no benefit to what you suggest and I actually see the potential for allot of harm.
Feelings like you posted are exactly the kind of things people like Osama exploit for crying out loud. You suggest "saving us" by becoming a slightly milder version of Osama himself.
Aren't peaceful American Nazis and peaceful American Communists also protected by the Constitution? I'd rather have one of them as a neighbor ---especially if I was a Jew.