Yes, my reasoning is mature (taking your sarcasm out of context). Seems to me that you are taking shots at Palestrina now. are you implying that he is inferior?
It is so far beyond me that I won't respond other than to note those on this thread there are those who imagine themselves experts and who are so sure of this and that but, in reality, are really very ignorant as to the real facts of Catholic Liturgical History. (And, notice there never seem to be admissions of errors or apologies by these imagined experts)
That ignorance accounts for a lot of the errors in the extremist camp. Combining ignorance with arrogance leads to schism far too frequently.
BTW, I am WELL aware of my ignorance. There are MANY on these threads who know a LOT more than me. That is why I am so submissive to the Magisterium. I don't rely on my own intellect/knowledge. I rely on the Universal Permanent Living Magisterium Jesus established