I’ve run into that same arguement from one FR O’Keefe in an article I read somewhere. Don’t know much about Scotus. If the main assertion is, as I read it, that the Incarnation is an actual ontological fact throughout history then I believe we would face some real difficult theological challenges. Perhaps a different categorical claim could be made.
Thanks for writing. Grace to you.
So any position he holds is going to be far from the likes of Blessed John Duns Scotus, St. Francis de Sales, or St. Lawrence of Brindisi who at least believed that Jesus was God and that he redeemed us from our sins.