[Frumanchu]

Doomed from the get go because of the ridiculous nature of the original article.

It may not have led to much in the way of productive conversation because of the controversy surrounding the document in question...but that's not the point. The point is threads like this NEVER will so long as a particular group can cry victim and strong arm their way into the discussion to disrupt it.

I've had some particularly interesting and productive discussions with some Orthodox folks in the past, but without fail those discussions get derailed and fall apart as soon as Roman Catholics push their way in and go on the offensive.

It seems as though productive ecumenical discussion is only allowed if they are the initiators and they get to steer the discussion.

[Mad Dawg]

The point is threads like this NEVER will so long as a particular group can cry victim and strong arm their way into the discussion to disrupt it.

Well, who's crying victim now?

A case was made, and evidently considered legitimate, that chapter 10 contained a violation of the rules pertaining to Caucus threads. Moderatori locutus, causa finita.