Sorry Harley, but you’ve repeated a lie. Christ’s atonement was ONCE. Jesus’s act of physical death happened ONCE in our timeline. God sees it as in revelation. You can argue with John of Patmos if you wish.
Sorry Cronos but it is NOT a lie. It is imbedded in Catholic doctrine and can be read on New Advent. Here is a comparison of the Reformed version and the Catholic version of the atonement is according to the Catholic website, "Called to Communion". Keep in mind the typical bias interpretation of the text like "God the Father hated, cursed and damned His Son, who was evil in the Fathers sight on account of all the sins of the elect".
The Reformed conception of the Atonement is that in Christs Passion and death, God the Father poured out all of His wrath for the sins of the elect, on Christ the Son. In Christs Passion and death, Christ bore the punishment of the Fathers wrath that the elect deserved for their sins. In the Reformed conception, this is what it means to bear the curse, to bear the Fathers wrath for sin. In Reformed thought, at Christs Passion and death, God the Father transferred all the sins (past, present, and future) of all the elect onto His Son. Then God the Father hated, cursed and damned His Son, who was evil in the Fathers sight on account of all the sins of the elect being concentrated in the Son. (R.C. Sproul says that here.) In doing so, God the Father punished Christ for all the sins of the elect of all time. Because the sins of the elect are now paid for, through Christs having already been punished for them, the elect can never be punished for any sin they might ever commit, because every sin they might ever commit has already been punished. For that reason Reformed theology is required to maintain that Christ died only for the elect. Otherwise, if Christ died for everyone, this would entail universal salvation, since it would entail that all the sins of all people, have already been punished, and therefore cannot be punished again. The Catholic conception of Christs Passion and Atonement is that Christ offered Himself up in self-sacrificial love to the Father, obedient even unto death, for the sins of all men. The Father was never angry with Christ. Nor did the Father pour out His wrath on the Son. The Passion is Christs greatest act of love, the greatest revelation of the heart of God, and the glory of Christ.1 So when Christ was on the cross, God the Father was not pouring out His wrath on His Son; in Christs act of self-sacrifice in loving obedience to the Father, Christ was most lovable in the eyes of the Father. Rather, in Christs Passion we humans poured out our enmity with God on Christ, by what we did to Him in His body and soul. And He freely chose to let us do all this to Him. Deeper still, even our present sins contributed to His suffering, because He, in solidarity with us, grieved over all the sins of the world, not just the sins of the elect. Hence, St. Francis of Assisi said, Nor did demons crucify Him; it is you who have crucified Him and crucify Him still, when you delight in your vices and sins.2 The Passion is a revelation of the love of God, not the wrath of God.
Called to Communion