Posted on 11/11/2011 9:38:23 AM PST by Alex Murphy
At Penn State, a month after the revelation of a sex-abuse scandal, four top executives have been ousted. In the American Catholic hierarchy, a decade after the exposure of hundreds of sex-abuse cases, just one bishop has resigned.
So now the American bishops know what it looks like when an institution takes its responsibilities seriouslyits responsibility not only to curb abusers, but also to hold accountable those leaders who allowed the abuse to go unchecked.
A university president, a vice-president, an athletic director, and a legendary football coach have been dismissed for doing once what many American bishops did multiple times. The trustees of Penn State have sent out a clear message: The sexual abuse of children is a heinous crime, and those who cover up the abuse share the guilt. The American Catholic bishops have very clearly grasped the first part of that message, and just as clearly failed to come to terms with the second part.
The students who noisily protested the firing of Joe Paterno also failed to grasp the point about holder leaders accountable. They admire Paterno for his coaching prowess, and understandably so. They say that he has made enormous contributions to Penn State, and they are right; there is already a statue of the man on campus. But even great men can do bad things. By failing to take appropriate action against an abuser, Paterno wrote his own sad ending to what should have been a stellar career.
The angry students at Penn State are showing a very natural human tendency. They admire Joe Pa, and dont want to think ill of him. They recognize that he made a major mistake, but dont think he should be punished for it. Couldnt we just cut the man some slack?
Perhaps Paterno himself was thinking along similar lines when he first heard the complaints against Jerry Sandusky. Presumably the old coach liked his assistant, and didnt want to make trouble for him. So he handled the matter quietlyand the abuser went unpunished, and more children were put at risk.
No doubt the same sort of sentimental thinking took place in chanceries all around the country (all around the world, it seems), when Church officials learned that Father X had been accused. Father X has done wrong, but hes fundamentally a good man, the bishops and monsignors might have said. Lets help him to work his way out of this problem gracefully. So the priest was quietly removed from his parish, given a few weeks of therapy, and then returned to a new assignment, where he had new opportunities to molest young people.
We all tend to make excuses for the people closest to us. Apparently that tendency affects even the most vociferous critics of clerical abuse. But even if it is a very natural weakness, it remains a weakness. If we want to eliminate the abuse of children, we must get tough with abusers. Sometimes that might mean fighting off the temptation to make excuses for themin effect, getting tough with ourselves.
Post of the month! Congrats!
Ignore them and they will fade away. They are not the first ecclesiastical revolutionaries to attack Holy Mother the Church and the popes and they won't be the last.
Ubi Petrus, ibi ecclesia!
Roma locuta, causa finita! God bless you and yours. Blessed John Paul, pray for us and for them.
Phil Lawler and Catholic Culture are Catholic-hating left-wing Catholics?
I’m a Latin-rite convert from Anglicanism. I don’t have much sympathy for the SSPX folks. Obedience is a virtue.
Mahoney was bad, but Weakland was even worse. They are finally gone. Weakland was an appointee of Paul VI back in ‘77. Mahoney was consecrated in ‘75. Law was consecrated back in ‘73.
Law, Weakland, Mahoney, et al, were elevated to bishops all prior to Pope John Paul’s papacy.
Again, look at the bishops that Pope John Paul elevated during his long pontificate. That the problem has been dealt with is evidence that Pope John Paul did not coddle the abuse.
He is a great pope. Really, he is and I was fortunate enough to make it under his pontificate.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.