[metmom]

Do note that just a year ago she was the nice poster — someone who has a background in one Protestant faith, of our Jewish friends.

Care to provide some evidence of that?

Because not many people I know have ever noticed it, including some not so regulars on the Catholic threads.

[Cronos]

Sure -- you know that more than anyone, met. You want evidence, remember you asked for it, so check here where Judith first pointed out that Are your politics separate from your religion? Is your religion separate from your finances? Is your religion separate from your vote? Do you keep God in a compartment where He cannot influence the rest of your life?

your post then condemned all Catholics as "consistently and predictably vot"ing in a certain manner and your post accused us all of "condone murder and mockery of marriage and sexual perversion?" to which Judith was pretty calm to say "Catholics who attend mass weekly, unlike the huge numbers of liberal protestants, do not vote for CINOS, do not contribute to CCHD, do not support abortion under any circumstances, do not support gay marriage, do not support the use of embryonic stem cells, and do not vote for those who do.

I suspect you already knew that, but could not resist the calumny."

you, metmom then when it has been pointed out that your posts blanket statement about Catholics was wrong, state "How can you seriously expect us to believe.. that you know the voting habits of all Catholics well enough to be able to make blanket statements like that?"

to which Judith was calm enough to say "The fact that I am not going to answer you does not mean I cannot refute you, it means that this discussion is over for me. The incredible rudeness of some of the posts has become intolerable."

did it not strike that the original post of yours HAD blanket statements in the first place?

[Cronos]

or there’s another there where you metmom compare our beliefs to “doctrines of demons” — Judith comes back with “We disagree. But thank you for the post.” — now isn’t that a nice poster? I meant Judith, not your original post.