Carrie is FAR from the Dixie Chicks. The Dixie Chicks mocked the President and other things. Carrie was asked a question and answered it honestly. I read her answer and the first part is fine but I don’t agree with her on this ONE TOPIC. Not enough by a mile for her fans to drop her. Now if she starts going out and publicly selling this than that would be a problem, but so far if this is where it ends than she might survive this.
“The Dixie Chicks mocked the President and other things.”
Better mocking GWB than God...
If Carrie Underwood were a professed atheist and said she supported gay marriage, then fine, that's her opinion and I don't agree with it, but she has a right to freedom of speech. The problem is she's claiming to be a "devout Christian" who supports gay marriage. That's false advertising. Gay marriage is not compatable with the bible or traditional Christianity. She may sincerely think that she "follows Jesus" (Muslims think they do too, he's a prophet in their religion) but she is not practicing traditional Christianity. If her church is a real Christian church, then her minister would object to her position and she would be violating church teachings.