[CTrent1564]

daniel212:

I would say schismatic in most cases and in many cases hold to objective heretical opinions, but given that Heretic is defined very precisely as a post baptismal rejection of a Doctrine of the Catholic Faith, a 500 year removed Protestant from his or her Catholic ancestors can’t be charged with the sin of schism or heresy of their ancestors. That is also a heretical to make such a claim.

Msg. Pope’s homily solidly lays out the Catholic position, of which I, as many others here hold to, you don’t hold to it. So be it.

[daniel1212]

a 500 year removed Protestant from his or her Catholic ancestors can’t be charged with the sin of schism or heresy of their ancestors. That is also a heretical to make such a claim.

Other RCs disagree with as much certitude. Such is an example of the interpretive disagreement seen among RCs.

[Elsie]

Msg. Pope’s homily solidly lays out the Catholic position, of which I, as many others here hold to, you don’t hold to it. So be it.

My beloved BIBLE solidly lays out the Christian position, of which I, as many others here hold to, you don’t accept unless it has been approved from Rome. So it is.