[metmom]

If the Protestant Reformers, most notably Martin Luther, were discontented with the sale of indulgences, which most informed Catholics will admit was not the way things were meant to be, why was the idea of Purgatory rejected completely, instead of simply rejecting the sale of indulgences?

Because it is not mentioned anywhere in Scripture nor is it even alluded to.

The only thing that cleanses us from sin is the blood of Jesus. Suffering can't do it.

So this is considered a false teaching leading some to conclude that there's another way for our sins to be dealt with than by trusting in Jesus.

[RoosterRedux]

why was the idea of Purgatory rejected completely, instead of simply rejecting the sale of indulgences?

What she said.:-)

It leads to a works theology.

When I do good works, it is because I love God, not because I am trying to earn something.

[Grateful2God]

The only thing that cleanses us from sin is the blood of Jesus. Suffering can't do it.

So in other words, some other mainstream denominations do not believe in redemptive suffering, except for that of Jesus. Thank you for clearing that up! I didn't know.

Ok, yet another genuine inquiry: how do you feel when St. Paul said he was making up in his body what is lacking in the Suffering of Christ?

Thank you!