If the government and its anti-family legislation were out of the way, people would naturally form associations and many of them will be religious in nature. Pretty soon abortion and public display of sodomy will be punished by customary laws in nearly every legislation. This is how libertarianism and conservatism ARE compatible.
When propagandists of either description use selective libertarian doctrines in the environment where he government is telling people how to live their lives from womb to tomb, the outcomes are grotesque, but that is not strictly libertarianism’s fault.
We have legal abortion, gay marriage creep, sexual deviancy, plus big big govt, a super surveillance state, massive corruption in govt, high high high taxes, dismantling of the Constitution, and no true representation.. now...and this all happened under Democrats and Republicans, there never has been a Libertarian party or President in power.