[MHGinTN]

Catholics are ripe for satan’s chrislam, as evidenced by their inability to discern the author of Islam. Even as the murderous nature of the father of Islam plays out, catholics continue to remain willfully clueless ... congratulations, your blindness is perfected, catholics. {/sarcasm}

[Legatus]

Catholics are ripe for satan’s chrislam, as evidenced by their inability to discern the author of Islam.

This disturbs me because it rings true. The CCC DOES allow that islam and the Church worship the same God... I doubt the mohammedans would agree. I think the argument that since islam is monotheistic therefore we must be worshiping the same God is ridiculous, completely worthy of ridicule.

OTOH, Belloc makes a very good case that islam did start as a heresy outside of the Church, but I think the final nature of their god is so radically NOT Divine that confusing the two deities is unacceptable.