[nickcarraway]

If you're not going to be Catholic, why be Catholic?

[Antoninus]

If you're not going to be Catholic, why be Catholic?

I suspect that the simple fact of the matter is that they are not only "not Catholic" but they HATE the Catholic Church to such an extent that they believe they are doing a good work by trying to tear it down from the inside. The dissenters must be chased out. Enough is enough.

[livius]

"If you're not going to be Catholic, why be Catholic?"

Because they're proud and arrogant and want to reshape the Church in their own image. And we all know where pride and arrogance come from...from the one who is also responsible for that whiff of sulphur that seems to permeate the air at these seminaries.