Are you wanting me to dig you out of your quagmire? (Anyway, I am way too busy at present to get any more involved in this discussion, and it won't get any better for about 3 weeks.)
Even if Justin Martyr speaks of the saints ruling with Christ in Jerusalem, and not Milwaukee, why does this negate an a-mill position? Don't you expect that the new heavens, and the new earth (to include the new Jerusalem) are going to last forever?
I think that you haven't thought enough about this yet.