Posted on 12/08/2017 10:29:39 AM PST by GoldenState_Rose
Most true musicians agree Bach was the principal master.
Certainly he was the master of “busy” music.
But for me lacking in dramatic intensity. I much prefer Beethoven, Brahms and Black Sabbath.
Oh, and Mahler. Can’t forget the last master of the German tradition.
Beautiful pieces. I'd love to hear Jenny Wong's version.
I love Mahler. My personal favorite has always been Das Lied von der Erde.
I enjoy this type of music, more the orchestral parts than the vocals, but I’ve always wanted to be a conductor and be paid large sums of money for waving my arms around.
These Bach chorales are haunting masterpieces.
Most folks don’t realize the depth and breadth of sounds that can be produced with the human voice alone.
If I was limited to one word in describing the various composers, I’d say “solemnity” best describes Bach.
Haydn — “precision”
Mozart — “exuberance”
Sebelius — “pride”
Grieg — “mystery”
Handel — “staid”
Wagner — “sweeping”
Beethoven — “majesty”
Chopin?
I enjoy this type of music, more the orchestral parts than the vocals, but Ive always wanted to be a conductor and be paid large sums of money for waving my arms around.
...
Me too, but I didn’t care about the money. My Dad hated the idea.
“These Bach chorales are haunting masterpieces.”
—
I like Bach, but as I mentioned, it’s the instrumentals that do it for me. String quartets are prob my fave.
“Me too, but I didnt care about the money. My Dad hated the idea.”
—
Only job where having to keep your hands in plain sight isn’t a bad situation.
:D
Ahhhhhh.....Bach!
I would disagree with Handel as Staid. His concertos alone are quite daring in many ways; but his music is serious and somewhat in the traditional sense. I would definitely agree that Mozart can be characterized as Exuberant.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E2j-frfK-yg&list=RDipzR9bhei_o&index=6
Bach, Air (”on the G string”, string orchestra)
Complex.
It’s hard to describe Handel in a single word. He could write works as lilting as The Harmonious Blacksmith, as soaring as the Messiah, and as stodgy as some of his later oratorios. Maybe I’ve judged him too harshly ...
Chopin-Romance
Personally, I’m partial to Stravinsky and Haydn.
Agreed. Handel wrote the exuberant Music for the Royal Fireworks and the inspirational yet intensely personal And He Feed His Flock in the Messiah. So it really is difficult to describe any of these great composers or compositions in one word or as the greatest ever. I used to think Bach’s Mass in B Minor was the greatest work. Then I performed the Berlioz Requiem. Two great works but very, very different. How is it possible to say one is “greater” than the other when they are so different?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.