Posted on 08/08/2007 9:49:49 AM PDT by Salvation
"Forever and inviolate" LOL. This so reminds me of what I was just reading in jude:16: "and their mouth speaketh great swelling words, having men's persons in admiration because of advantage". The persons in admiration sure reminds me of RC's constant habit of droping the names of "church fathers" and popes as if that trumps scipture.
What we got here (try this suggestion) is so radical a difference in ecclesiology that we can't even agree what the difference is. I love it!
I understand Shea to say that because we filthy papists acknowledge the "churchiness" of the "Orthodox" therefore, at least functionally, the obvious distinguishing mark is the sacrament. The "Orthodox" got it, but you ain't got it - and don't even want it. So that makes it the "flag" or whatever.
It seems to me he can't believe that with great theological rigor. If an Arian showed up and said "Oh yes, we believe in the real presence and all that; we just don't believe Jesus is Divine," My guess is Shea would say, "Oh yeah, that too."
But you, DM, are saying that for YOU, the real deal is that we have a notion of what I propose we call "authoritative revelation" which differs profoundly from the "protestant" notion.
It's kind of a version of the word v. sacrament controversy that also divides us! Shea is saying we're apart because of a difference about THE sacrament, and you're saying we're apart because of a difference about "authoritative revelation" or "the Word".
What made me cheer for Shea was not so much the Sacrament as the only opinion which divides us but his presentation of the problem that it seems that if a bunch of people say,"The RCs are wrong," that's considered a good thing, while if the RC's say, "Well, no actually, we think you're wrong," that's considered the Nazi Pope dragging the Church back into the dark ages and "hyper-denominationalism" and blah blah. And his, I thought, appropriate trashification of the "Can't we all just get along" side of ecumenism by saying that adoring the sacrament aor asking Mary for intercessions for the "poor souls in Purgatory", quite expectedly and unremarkably gives our protestant brethren the heebie-jeebies.
Mirabile dictu is it almost tolerable outside this evening. It has been vicious!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.