Posted on 07/03/2019 12:05:17 PM PDT by Liberty7732
When working in newsrooms in the 1990s, my journalism colleagues often asked me why Rush Limbaugh was so popular. They could not fathom it. I explained it was basic supply meeting pent-up demand; that is, conservatives had felt under attack in every area of media and here came a guy with a microphone giving voice to their worldview, and providing analysis and twists that were done no where else.
Limbaugh ushered in a revolution of talk radio hosts, creating an entire industry known as conservative talk radio and probably saving the AM dial. Before Fox News, conservative talk radio stood alone in the flood of liberal media. And spawned Sean Hannity, Glenn Beck, Hugh Hewitt, Dennis Prager, Laura Ingraham and more. Most of these hosts are Baby Boomers and have a fairly set way of thinking and doing. (Notably, Beck the least in that regard, via both worldview and business model, and Prager with Prager U.) A lot of conservatism has reflected that old set way — at least in the Republican base.
But now we have something new in Ben Shapiro, who is arguably the most popular conservative in the country, although Rush and Sean fans may dispute that. Shapiro’s been on the scene for awhile, starting with a nationally syndicated column at 17 years old. But he’s exploded in recent years with the largest conservative podcast, a newly minted national radio show and best-selling books, while still writing for the Daily Wire and acting as Editor.
He’s simply sprinted past all of the much older and more established radio commentators.
Why? What makes Shapiro different?
Yes, he is smart, fast-talking, aggressive yet reasonable and has a quantum hard-drive for a memory. His worldview as a Christian-friendly, Orthodox Jew millennial conservative is almost hilariously unique. He’s fearless taking on the Left and usually acquits himself with a good pummelling. People eat up his “Ben Shapiro destroys…” Youtube videos usually answering questions at college campuses. He’s just a fresh voice in so many ways.
But there’s something else going on, and why people like me also gravitate to Shapiro. He simply puts more meat on the bone than the talk radio predecessors, throws far fewer bombs, rants less and more frequently explains what the other side is thinking or strategizing — fairly or not dependent on your worldview.
For too long, many of our talk radio hosts have spit out the same name-calling invectives and one-sided rants that have felt good but have not prepped any listener for dealing with an informed liberal. I can always tell my conservative friends who spend a lot of time listening to conservative talk radio. The vernacular is well-repeated. It too often boils down to: liberals are evil, they’re idiots, they hate America, and they think we’re all “racist, sexist, bigot, homophobes.” OK. Fair enough. Got it. But now what?
This is not a shot at these guys. I remember hearing Rush for the first time around 1989 or 1990 driving on U.S. 67 north of the Quad-Cities along the Mississippi River on the way home from my newspaper job in Davenport, flipping through stations when I came across this guy saying what I believe. I listened for a few minutes and was drop-jawed. This was no where else! I pulled into a dirt driveway, put it in park and just listened.
Supply was just beginning to meet demand and Rush was the pioneer.
Free Market Health Care PAC The Revolutionary Act supports the work of the Free Market Health Care PAC But the supply of good red-meat conservative insights and rants (which I like as much as the next guy) is exceeding demand and has for awhile as everyone seeks to get in on the schtick. The typical pendulum of supply and demand seeking equilibrium and rarely finding it.
I’ve long wanted more, and sought it out in books and podcasts. Particularly podcasts in recent years where I can get long-form interviews and more in-depth information than what feels like the same old, same old on radio.
Shapiro goes at least part way toward meeting that demand. He provides reams more data and context on issues. While standard talk radio tells you X is a terrible idea. Shapiro frequently tells you why X is a terrible idea. That is a big step forward and one that obviously conservative millennials are attracted to — and there are growing numbers of those — but also that older conservatives are drawn to.
If Shapiro is roughly Rush 2.0 30 years later — William F. Buckley without the pretensions — then what we’re likely to see is a lot of people following his footsteps, just as we saw an entire industry follow Rush’s. We’re already seeing that with young conservative personalities. But young ranters a la old ranters is not the future. Depth, context, data and fearlessness with opponents (Rush never debates a liberal) may well be — and that does not have an age requirement attached.
Further, Shapiro’s radio program is utilizing his podcast format on radio, which has the potential to revolutionize a somewhat ossified radio industry facing stiffening competition from podcasts and new media.
Shapiro’s style and altered format — if it works — could be one of the healthier trends long-term for conservatism by creating a new breed of conservative-thought influencers, building on the first generation with a new and updated model that leaves conservatives more informed and armed than the 1.0 version.
RE: Shapiro has some good conservative ides, but outside that he’s a sissy cuck never Trumper so screw him.
He supported :
* Trump’s move of the embassy to Jerusalem
* Trump’s support of Israel
* The border wall
* Corporate tax cuts but is not especially fond of the individual tax laws
* Neil Gorsuch but was a reluctant about Brett Kavanaugh
How is that being a NeverTrumper?
Can anyone post a link to video of him supporting Hillary?
Can’t listen to that voice...not even his commercials.
Shapiro was NOT for trump in 2016.
He however, admits today that most of his impressions about Trump were wrong ( for instance, he thought Trump was for Planned Parenthood, he now admits that Trump is strong on the pro-life cause ).
That is NOT a NeverTrumper,
Lil’ Ben is a nasty NeverTrumper & emotion driven RINO (at best).
His interview by Bill Maher when both were gleefully calling for impeachment showed his true colors.
At his core, he’s just another leftwing phony.
RE: There does not seem to be any issue about which his position is fixed.
If you listen to him, he DOES have fixed positions — Mostly Conservative, small government, pro-life, strong border, pro-Israel, restrained spending, originalist judges, free trade stances.
That he did not think Trump would be all these in 2016 was his mistake, which he now admits.
The only thing that little prick is doing to media is driving people away from it.
See post 11
Precisely
RE: Lil’ Ben is a nasty NeverTrumper & emotion driven RINO (at best).
If he were a NeverTrumper, he would be opposing Trump’s policies at every turn. That he supports MOST of Trump’s policies shows that he is NOT a NeverTrumper.
As for his being a leftwing phony, can you show me which policies he supports that are left-wing?
He’s never had a real job. He is just like Bill Kristol and George Will only younger
I agree. That voice is like nails on a chalkboard. Can’t listen at all.
Shapiro is a great asset. I much enjoy his rational style. Invective doesn’t go far with me.
I enjoyed reading about the early days of Rush. I remember the first time I heard him, too. I was driving across the Sf-Oakland bay bridge in the eighties. I was flabbergasted. I went home and told my husband “you would not believe what I just heard.” It was revolutionary. Previously isolated by the “fairness doctrine” I felt as though I had stumbled into reality and it was so enervating.
I don’t listen to the talk shows hardly anymore. They used to be be funnier for one thing. They are VERY repetitive for another. Tons of commercials. But mostly I don’t like feeling like my anger is being stoked all the time.
There is much to be angry about. But my wrath does not accomplish good. I prefer to be informed, and entertained, and to understand, and to be helped in formulating my opinions and arguments. Shapiro does that. So does Jordan Peterson. Dennis Prager (prager u). These are the resources that I go to regularly now.
RE: Over-rated and deeply impressed with himself.
Why does this not apply to Rush Limbaugh, who calls himself “Doctor of Democracy”, the “Maha Rushi”, one who defeats Liberals with “Half my brain tied behind my back just to make it fair”, “The weapon of Mass Instruction” with “Talent on Loan from God” etc.
I don’t know where this came from, many,MANY see him as an annoying little puke.
A fried once told me that German Shepherds are the very best dog to train. “They are smart enough to outsmart themselves.” He was fond of saying.
Shapiro outsmarts himself by getting tangled in his inner logic and venting his ideological tripe.
Dinesh D’Souza is much better at elucidating liberal positions and knocking them down with historial facts.
His whiny nasel delivery is a channel changer for me.
Ben’s reaction to Notre Dame fire was last straw for me. Started suspecting he didn’t care for Christians a few years back when discussing Syria and general ME policy. After Notre Dame, saw the light, he’s no good.
RE: He’s never had a real job.
Isn’t being a talk show host and writing books and columns a job?
He also practiced law at Goodwin Procter. As of March 2012 he ran an independent legal consultancy firm, Benjamin Shapiro Legal Consulting, in Los Angeles.
If those are not jobs, what are they? At least he isn’t taking money from tax payers.
His speech pattern sounds like a hamster with Tourette’s Syndrome on crack.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.