Posted on 09/22/2015 10:39:36 AM PDT by Starman417
One of my favorite teachers in high school was Mr. Kelly. Ostensibly he was a reading teacher, but his interests were far more inclined towards history and cultures. We once got into a discussion about the great cultures throughout history. The obvious names came up the Greeks, the Egyptians, the Romans, Aztecs, ancient China etc. Then he asked the question about what determines a great culture. My answer was something like: A great culture leaves something tangible behind. My reasoning was simply that whether the Parthenon, the Coliseum, various pyramids or the Great Wall of China, all of these cultures left tangible representations of their greatness. Mr. Kelly then posited that maybe that was the wrong measure. Maybe instead we should measure a cultures greatness by the vibrancy of life enjoyed by its people during its heyday. In particular he mentioned two cultures in western Africa who left nary a trace of their existence, but apparently had a vibrant society centuries ago. He suggested that it was possible that they were every bit as great as the cultures as those we usually mention when discussing history. I was skeptical but it was an interesting discussion.
Sadly, after 30 years I dont remember the cultures he mentioned. But I do remember the question itself of how we go about measuring great cultures. That question is very much relevant today. Since then I cant remember how many times Ive heard various professors or pundits or pontificators suggest something like All cultures are equal and deserve the same level of respect. Im as skeptical about that today as when I first heard it. Yesterdays New York Times provided a perfect example of that exact thing. In it was a story titled: U.S. Soldiers Told to Ignore Sexual Abuse of Boys by Afghan Allies. The various Marines and soldiers who became aware of the abuse were told by higher ups that they could not intervene because it was their culture. Indeed, a number of American servicemembers who took steps to stop the rampant pederasty were disciplined and even kicked out of the military.
This story comes on the heels of two other events that bring up the question of cultures. Europe is being invaded by millions of Muslims. The United States is being invaded by millions of Mexicans and others from Latin Americans.
Today we find ourselves in a situation where the West, home to the greatest accomplishments of mankind, are under siege by migrants from cultures and nations that are abject failures. The West in general, and the United States in particular, are the home of the greatest advances in human history or in some cases harnessing innovations from elsewhere: Computers. Man on the moon. Mapping of the Human Genome. Flight. Nuclear power. The Mechanical Reaper. Air conditioning. The automobile. Plastic. Electricity. Add to those things that are essential to Western, or at least American culture: Representative government. Limited government. The outlawing of slavery. Freedom of speech and the press. Freedom of worship. Individual rights. Private property. Together these things have allowed the West to create nations where more people have enjoyed more prosperity, more freedom, and longer lives than any people in history.
Prosperity, freedom and longevity may not be the best measures of a cultures greatness, but they are probably pretty close. Of course that doesnt mean that either the United State or the West are perfect. They are not, not by a long shot. But for all of their failures they are by and large exponentially better places to live than the rest of the world.
Its thus strange then that many of the beneficiaries of these advanced cultures seek to diminish them and draw an equivalency with other cultures, regardless of the reality. In much of the Muslim world women are 2nd class citizens at best. Homosexuals are murdered. The freedoms of speech or the press or religion are virtually nonexistent. Most of the population lives in poverty, or not far above it. And of course there is the near constant threat of terrorism or war, as more than half of the ongoing conflicts on the planet involve Muslims.
Then there is Mexico and Latin America where the economies are in constant turmoil, where corruption is a way of life, where governments know few if any limits and where drug cartels reign supreme via bribes and brutality.
None of those things create a foundation for prosperity or freedom or longevity. But somehow not only are Americans and Westerners supposed to respect these dystopian cultures as equals, at the same time we are supposed to welcome the masses escaping them into our communities. It would be one thing if the vast majority of these migrants were seeking to assimilate into their new locales and contribute to their prosperity. Theyre not. In Europe Muslims are seeking to apply sharia law in enclaves across the continent - UK - France and trying to bend the locals to their mores... including outlawing Octoberfest in Germany!. Ninety percent of Middle Eastern refugees are on food stamps and Asian rape gangs proliferate, seemingly without fear. In the United States illegal immigrants receive government assistance at twice the rate of the native population while in some places they are responsible for over 1/3 of the murders and other violent crimes.
Unfortunately, the subject of culture is no longer simply an academic question to be discussed in Social Studies class. Today the question implies real world consequences such as poverty and death. While Muslim or African or Hispanic cultures may have positive aspects about them, and may have been great at one time long ago in history, today they are largely dysfunctional and often abject failures where the citizenry suffer great calamity both economic and physical.
(Excerpt) Read more at floppingaces.net...
All things considered, I'd rather take a million Mexicans than even a thousand muslims.
MY culture has matured for ME and it is perfect for me and mine
No other culture "fits in" to mine and must give way to my culture
My culture is from and for my nation and we nationals want it to remain ours
That's a whole bunch'a personal pronouns but THAT is exactly what a culture is .... personal to the person it belongs to.
bkmk
On the "great culture" scale, radical Islam gets negative points. I don't want to see a list of all the great monuments and artifacts that ISIS and the Taliban have destroyed in my lifetime, because it would be depressing, but they have erased history, erased tourist and historical attractions, set education back several generations (or more), and destroyed everything they have touched. Oddly, almost all great structures within their control date from before Islam - almost like nothing new has been built in the Islamic world for fifteen centuries. I cannot imagine why that is true.
All cultures are equal and deserve the same level of respect
Like those that allow cannibalism or pedophilia? That kind of tripe is the “liberals” ticket to setting up a totalitarian government. I think they call it “multiculturalism”.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.