Posted on 09/17/2009 9:04:57 PM PDT by AncientAirs
Our democratic rule is based on theoretic relativism. Truth or order is its principal antagonist. If we admit truth, we deny liberty. The resultant moral chaos is acknowledged. But we do not address the cause and the consequences remain. They require a new politics of care for the whole society.
But this care cannot be personal. It is non-preferential, egalitarian, same-for-all. Government is its best administrator. If people do whatever they want, they often must be taken care of. They are primarily victims of themselves and of old structures. They need someone to do for them what they cannot do for themselves.
Everyone needs equal access to what anyone else has. The natural distinctions caused by differing talents, wills to work, habits, and virtue are unjust. They cause the poor to be poor. Human nature needs some change.
We become more of a one-party, central command system. The state is all-caring. We are not the best judges of our own good. Our model is not ourselves and our wretched traditions. The president does not speak of American standards being good for the world, but of (selective) world standards being good for us. We should imitate the world and apologize to it. Our uniqueness has caused most of the wars and unbalances in the world.
Looking over his initiatives, Victor Davis Hanson remarked that, on balance, the president is neither a pragmatist, as he insisted, nor even a liberal, as charged. Rather he is a statist. The president believes that a select group of affluent, highly educated technocrats supported by a phalanx of whiz-kids fresh out of blue-chip universities with little or no experience in the market place, can direct our lives for better than we can ourselves. The people have lost their grip. They need to be guided, taken care of for the common good.
Out of democracys chaos, Plato said, will arise a leader. Such a leader, Fouard Ajami writes, is familiar: (The presidents) politics of charisma was reminiscent of the Third World. He was familiar to Aristotle too.
So taxes are designed that wealth be redistributed. Everyone deserves about the same things in pay, health-care, education, and vacations. Anything else is unjust. We will make it happen. All will be cared for.
The fatal steps along this path were taken freely by a free people. They forgot that freedom not based in truth is license.
In Sermon 7 of Subjects of the Day, Newman wrote: The world has many sins, but its peculiar offence is that of daring to reason contrary to Gods Word and will. It puts wrong aims before itself, and acts towards them. It goes wrong as if on principle, and prefers its own way of viewing things to Gods way. A better description of the present direction of our polity is difficult to find. We go wrong on principle.
James V. Schall, S.J., a professor at Georgetown University, is one of the most prolific Catholic writers in America. His most recent book is The Mind That Is Catholic.
(c) 2009 The Catholic Thing. All rights reserved. For reprint rights, write to: info at thecatholicthing dot org
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.