American Idol 2012--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 18, 2012

[silent_jonny]

That’s funny!

[Netizen]

Disregard my previous post. I just checked and all the people I mentioned were in the same season. So, you are right. LOL

Amy Adams
Camile Velasco
Diana DeGarmo
Fantasia Barrino
George Huff
Jasmine Trias
Jennifer Hudson
John Stevens
Jon Peter Lewis
Latoya London
Leah Labelle
Matt Rogers
William Hung

Not a particularly good season, Hudson should have won imo

[silent_jonny]

Tonight has been AWFUL...AWFUL...AWFUL!!!

I agree. The first 90 minutes was bad.

[Netizen]

Another remake. Who sang the original?

[silent_jonny]

There was so much great music in the early 90’s. I don’t understand why they keep picking the duds.

Iovine. He's out of touch.

[Netizen]

If--IF--they do eliminate someone tomorrow night, they're going to have to figure out a way to extend the season by a week.

Hope its not a beg a thon.

[Netizen]

Have you noticed Seacrest being more personable this year?

[Netizen]

They probably did, but, he was using fake names with the police. So, unless AI knew those fake names....

[retrokitten]

Hope its not a beg a thon.

[Netizen]

ROFLMAO

[Shelayne]

I seriously have no life.

I just watched the Youtube of Hudson getting cut. She was in the bottom three with Fantasia and LaToya. I cannot believe I remembered correctly. Jonathan, Jasmine, George Huff, and Diana were the top four. The judges were not happy, as they had figured Jonathan was a goner and Jennifer Hudson couldn’t believe the “three divas” were in the bottom. Her mouth was literally hanging open. I didn’t watch the whole thing, as I already know the ending. I remember that I liked LaToya London that season and disliked Fantasia and wanted her to lose.

I cannot remember what I had for breakfast, but I can remember this stupid episode. Hahahahaha! Loooo-hoooo-ser!

[Netizen]

LOL Think that’s bad. I thought the season was so bad I thought they were two different seasons!

I liked Hudson, DeGarmo and London. I still think they gave the win to Screamtasia. She had one good song and couldn’t even read. Which explains all her screaming and oh yeahs.

[Shelayne]

I think you’re right. I remember she sang Barry Manilow’s “It’s a Miracle” and sounded like, as Simon told her, either Donald or Daffy Duck. It was a total mess. They kept bringing up her daughter for the sympathy vote.

Then there was the whole thing with Diana’s earpiece in the finale. Hmmmm....

[Shelayne]

LOL! I agree!

[Yaelle]

Thank you!

[Yaelle]

Rofl!! They really played this up. Especially the “let him squirm on national tv” moment. I thought Nigel was going to tell him to get up and “danshe a sholo to shave your life!”. They should have had a cop come out right then and throw him down and cuff him. Sheesh.

And then Seacrest wishes him well. “when they let him out!”.

[Yaelle]

Way too soon!

[Yaelle]

It would have been humorous if he sung “When a man loves a crawfish”.

---

This got to me. I’ve LOL’ed twice over it.

[Yaelle]

Yes, we noticed it too. This was the first night in 2 years that Steven didn’t just tell everyone they were “beautiful, baby.”. It was pretty obvious he got told to be harder because he slammed everyone. Instead of “you are beautiful and I love the tone of your voice” it was “didn’t like it, pitchy” etc.

jLo was beautiful tonight. I think she’s the most beautiful known woman alive.

The singers were mostly boring as heck tonight. What boring songs. I liked the first guy, the “when a man loves a woman” guy, and the filipina.

[Chunga]

I'm with JLo...I think Joshua Ledet is the best male singer in the history of American Idol. Carrie Underwood and Katherine McPhee are better at this point...Jessica Sanchez might be as good.

People who don't like soul singers won't get him, though.