His British choice is "It's The Time Of The Season". BORING. I'm getting drowsy listening to it.
Randy: Very subdued, very relaxed Phil Phillips. We were like yo! He really can sing the melody. A lot more less energy type of vibe. It was a nice performance. Don't know if I'm jumping up and down.
J-Lo: Sounded like it could be your song. Did a good job with it.
Steven: Glad you chose that song and I'm glad you sang the melody. It's a crime NOT to sing the melody. You sang it really well. So good for you.
Phil Phillips just received the faint praise kiss of death from the judges.
No hyping him tonight
Not just boring — BAD.
If he would have sung that way for his original screening, he would have never made it Hollywood.
He chose a bizzare key and cadence. Even the singers and the band had problems with it. And he was pitchy.
And going right after Holly hit it out the park made it worse by comparison.