It’s clear that Plato describes the Atlantic (names it), Gibraltar, and gives the dimensions and era of an island, and states that it no longer exists — IOW, no, not Crete, Thera, or anywhere else in the Aegean.
Plato was right about ancient Troy?
Isn’t there some argument for Atlantis being some land adjacent to Cuba that apparently subsided?
The only thing is that of late it *appears* the Minoans 'fit better'. And with the current Sonar Imaging of the Atlantic Ocean 'if drained', it doesn't look like Atlantis could have been anywhere in it. The Mid-Atlantic Ridge runs right down the middle. Unless Atlantis was there and 'The Ridge' opened up and swallowed it whole? Maybe I'm watching too many 'expert documentaries' on the History Channel (H2). After all, It's not like they've never been wrong before ;-)
One other thing regarding 'Atlantis' being in the Atlantic Ocean area is very interesting though, The Bimini Road. Right now I can't buy that that 'Road of Blocks' was made by water currents and erosion as the 'Experts say'. And if prehistoric humans made that road, they had some hi-tech help. Those blocks are huge and would be a tough task today with our Big Construction Equip/Machines. Like that underwater 'Temple of Steps' off Japan's coast which is supposed to be 'naturally made' by sea currents (I don't think so).
Bottom line, I guess I'm torn on Atlantis. Two answers seem to fit.