Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

To: GCC Catholic

No, it is not absurd. A writer can spend ten years writing a book, living in dire poverty the entire time. He can live in abject isolation and lose his health, he can sustain permanent physical and emotional damage from trying to bring one book or piece of music to life. If the work later becomes acknowledged as a masterpiece, of course he and his heirs should have the right to benefit from his unique gifts and his extraordinary sacrifices.


14 posted on 12/10/2012 10:53:05 AM PST by kabumpo (Kabumpo)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies ]


To: kabumpo
You can spend ten years mining coal as well, living in dire poverty the entire time. You can lose you health, and sustain permanent physical and emotional damage from breaking your back in a coal mine all day. None of which guarantees him a free paycheck for the rest of his life, and it CERTAINLY doesn't guarantee one for his heirs.

Copyright is a socialistic concept, and while it does have a place, it's place must be limited. An idea is not a thing, and when an idea is shared nobody is deprived of anything. Copyright ensures compensation for the original creator, but it is, at it's core, nothing more than charity from the government and society in general. As with all government charity, it must be limited or it will inevitably lead to corruption (as our current system so clearly has).
18 posted on 12/10/2012 11:13:37 AM PST by Arthalion
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies ]

To: kabumpo; Arthalion
No, it is not absurd. A writer can spend ten years writing a book, living in dire poverty the entire time. He can live in abject isolation and lose his health, he can sustain permanent physical and emotional damage from trying to bring one book or piece of music to life. If the work later becomes acknowledged as a masterpiece, of course he and his heirs should have the right to benefit from his unique gifts and his extraordinary sacrifices.

I hadn't even thought of copyright as a socialistic concept until Arthalion had mentioned it, but I'm inclined to think he's right, especially after your explanation.

The hypothetical writer you describe is a "taker", seeking government welfare in the form of a perpetual protection of his one idea. I don't feel sympathy for such an artist who has put all his effort in his art to the detriment of his basic needs, for the same reason I don't feel sympathy for young athletes who are banking on becoming the next great professional athlete in their chosen sport -- the odds of a "big break" for both are pretty small. You need to have a marketable skill as a fallback.

If an artist wants to use his art as his livelihood, he needs to continue to create. I would point to someone like James Michener as one example of someone who has done this properly. He wrote his Tales of the South Pacific, and when that was successful he poured his royalties back into his writing, so that he could continue producing successful works of writing. Even under the old copyright laws, he would have been able to make a fine livelihood because he kept creating.

The old copyright protections gave a reasonable amount of time for the artist to produce another work without the fear of starving in the meantime. 42 years (28+14) is plenty. The reason why heirs benefiting perpetually is absurd is because they undermine the basic principle: granting the heirs that privilege doesn't forward the promotion of arts and sciences (unless, of course, they create something THEMSELVES, and get a copyright or patent of their own).

Beyond this, masterpieces become such by virtue of being widely known -- they enter into the common good, a common societal patrimony that in turn promotes other ideas. As such, they should and must belong to everyone -- perpetual copyright prevents that from happening. Likewise, any degree of copyright stifles some creativity, thus there are "fair use" provisions that even supersede copyright under certain specific circumstances.

23 posted on 12/10/2012 12:25:06 PM PST by GCC Catholic
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson