Mass Deporting of Dreamers and Other "Illegals" Would Help No One and Hurt Everybody

Janitor's view ^ | March 20, 2018J | Reasonmclucus

[Fresh Wind]

They are criminally invading our country with the encouragement and support of the Mexican government and trying to take it over for their own gain, while displacing actual Americans.

Just thought I'd add a bit to your statement!

[frnewsjunkie]

I could deal with that on these conditions:
1. They cannot vote for 7 years and have a U.S. citizenship
2. They not expect welfare
3. They have a place to live
4. They have a job
5. They learn to speak English
They come here and assimilate .. and never “expect” our government to support them.

[x]

That's not from Alinsky.

Some people say it's from Cloward and Piven.

[packrat35]

Yep , but we are told they are paying their fair share of taxes to cover their costs.

[packrat35]

Nothing is wrong with e-verify and self-deportation, along with actual real deportation to spearhead it.

[packrat35]

I agree.

[packrat35]

Yeah, lets screw over the real Americans that buy our products first

[packrat35]

"real Americans", what are you-a racist?

[packrat35]

I’m stealing that Wetdreamers line!

[SmokingJoe]

The “We can’t deport them all” is the biggest crock of all. It’s like saying we c can’t catch all murderers so we might as well stop trying to catch em. We don’t have to deport every single illegal before it’s successful. There is always going to be some wild eyed illegal out in the mountains or whatever. Just catch and deport as many as possible and make it hell for them to live here and the problem will take care of itself.

[packrat35]

If these illegals are so valuable to the USA, why weren’t they valuable to their home country?

Bears repeating!!!!

[packrat35]

I could deal with that on these conditions: 1. They cannot vote for 7 years and have a U.S. citizenship 2. They not expect welfare 3. They have a place to live 4. They have a job 5. They learn to speak English They come here and assimilate .. and never “expect” our government to support them.

Well in answer to your list, even if that passed into law, the Supreme Court would overrule them all. Hell most of them still can't speak English after living here for over 10 years.

[apocalypto]

All illegals should be deported. Period. I don't care how cute they are or what sob stories they tell. They have broken the law, and there is no reason to let them ahead of of those who want to enter legally. And it would send the message that some people are above the law.

To be a country, we, not the illegals, should control who is admitted. And we don't need immigrants from countries whose culture are incompatible with ours and who hate us.

[Yaelle]

Bull poop. Kids used to be able to get menial jobs in high school. Now an illegal father of 6 is the fast food guy and sweeps and works the strawberry fields.

Americans sin and drive drunk, but not to the extent socially permissible in Mexico. They drive smashed here every day and they don’t carry insurance.

They don’t care about education in Mexico so who would you want families here that use our schools as day cares and hold back American kids who could be progressing?

Our jails are overcrowded in CA so our debauched CA pols are emptying the jails of “non violent” felons like rapists and molesters. If we didn’t house so many illegals in our jails we would have room to jail our thieves again, even.

Life would be 1000x better without allowing illegals here.

[lizma2]

It’s not both? Read “Rules For Radicals” 2 decades ago and I remember this sentiment. Back then also read Cloward-Pivens. (I was pregnant. Looked at learning as protecting my kid to be.)

Thought RFR was a reprint of CP a few years later?

[papertyger]

Yeah, lets screw over the real Americans that buy our products first

That's the price we all need to pay to make sure the shareholders and small business leeches are happy.

[E. Pluribus Unum]

Straw man.

You don’t have to deport a single one.

Just stop giving them free stuff.

They’ll know what to do.

[Cobra64]

When I hear these amnesty creeps, I wonder what their reaction would be getting their throat slit, mugged, raped, or robbed by an illegal like an MS13 gang member.

[frnewsjunkie]

True.. this would have to be run through the SC before it could be used.. and one more item... that we get the WALL!!

[Tudorfly]

The article author is a clown, masquerading as someone with a rational perspective.