Posted on 03/31/2005 7:20:57 AM PST by mtntop3
Terri Schiavo's CT scan another physicians opinion March 31st, 2005
The amount of medical misinformation put out about Terri Schiavo has been truly stunning. The testimony of Terris physicians who believe that some recovery is possible has been largely dismissed. Judge Greers court and the media in turn, have focused only on the pessimistic interpretations of the raw data of her CT scan.
A physician at a credible physicians website has analyzed Terris CAT scan and concludes that it has been grossly misrepresented. There is some cerebral atrophy, but it is a completely inaccurate to characterize it as bag of water. Furthermore, the author states that
the most alarming thing about this image, however, is that there certainly is cortex left. Granted, it is severely thinned, especially for Terri's age, but I would be nonplussed if you told me that this was a 75 year old female who was somewhat senile but fully functional, and I defy a radiologist anywhere to contest that.
In one of the definitive court battles in 2002, five physicians examined Terri to determine if therapy would be of further benefit. Two chosen by Terris parents believed that she was not in a persistent vegetative state and that some recovery was possible. Two chosen by Michael Schiavo held that she had no chance of recovery, as did the neutral physician appointed by the court. This 3-2 decision was key in the 2003 attempt to pull her feeding tube.
One of Michael Schiavos medical experts was the right-to-die advocate Dr. Ronald Cranford, who has been an expert in a number other key court cases on our nations slippery slope to euthanasia, including those of Nancy Cruzan and Robert Wedlund. But Dr. Cranford has made serious errors in other cases when prognosticating about the prospects of neurological recovery. Frederica Mathewes-Green states that Sgt. David Mack, who was shot in the line of duty as a policeman, was diagnosed by Cranford as
"definitely...in a persistent vegetative state...never [to] regain cognitive, sapient functioning...never [to] be aware of his condition."
Twenty months after the shooting Mack woke up, and eventually regained nearly all his mental ability. When asked by a reporter how he felt, he spelled out on his letterboard, "Speechless!"
In fact, the entire field of diagnosing persistent vegetative state or PVS is fraught with inaccuracy. Recent studies have shown the rate of misdiagnosis to be as high as 37% or even 43%. PVS is a clinical diagnosis, meaning that it depends on the subjective judgment of the examining physician. Experts in the field cannot even agree on the usefulness of diagnostic imaging.
Dr. Ronald Cranford himself was upset about the articles showing the inaccuracy of diagnosis and prognostication about PVS. Childs and Mercer, authors of one of the studies citing the difficulties of diagnosing PVS, took Cranford to task for zealously promoting the concept of the "permanent vegetative state" despite the evidence of its problematic nature, and the regularity with which some patients recover from it .
The nomenclature of persistent vegetative state was coined in 1972 by Jennett and Plum in the prestigious medical journal The Lancet. The original article, Persistent Vegetative State: A syndrome in search of a name seems to have succeeded in its task as reclassifying severely cognitively disabled humans as non-persons - something akin to vegetables in the minds of many. Public perception of this highly-charged term predisposes many to dismiss the lives of human beings as no more significant than plant life. It is a brilliant, if chilling, masterstroke of propaganda, one which has been swallowed hook, line, and sinker.
This reclassification of non-terminally ill people has allowed for their dehydration and starvation deaths in Britain with a doctors recommendation, and in many states in the USA with the familys wishes (or a patients own advance directives). The medical literature is rife with arrogant pronouncements in editorials of learned journals, such as life itself not being of benefit to someone in the PVS state. The echoes of current bioethics doublespeak resound in these journals.
In some respects the persistent vegetative state is more a political than a medical diagnosis, as it allows its unfortunate victims to lose their right to life and be medically killed through withholding food and water. It is unfortunate that some of the experts on the side of the Culture of Death seem to have had the upper hand in Terris fight, and have been portrayed by the media as reasonable and responsible members of the medical profession, rather than the zealots which, in fact, some of their own medical colleagues have branded them.
Mary L. Davenport, MD
It's a moot point. Terri died at 9:05 AM this morning.
We must not give up the fight to keep this kind of killing from ever happening again.
Go to the original article for the many links.
ping
It's going to happen again, once something has been gotten away with it sets a precedent. The Courts killed this kind, gentle soul by allowing this to happen. Now you'll see them going after anyone who is unable to speak for themselves, and more than likely even those that are. It's a sad day for the US, may God have mercy on us.
Sanjay Gupta was just on CNN, saying that it was interesting that a number of doctors could perform the same neurological exams and get different results.
DuH!!
The condition of anybody varies from day to day.
That's why people keep track of their blood sugar level and their blood pressure from day to day.
The Lord is Terri's Shepherd --- That's Relationship !!!
She shall not want --- That's Supply !!!
He maketh her to lie down in green pastures --- That's Rest !!!
He leadeth her beside the still waters --- That's Refreshment !!!
He restoreth her soul --- That's Healing !!!
He leadeth her in the paths of righteousness --- That's Guidance !!!
For His name sake --- That's Purpose !!!
Yea, though Terri walks through the valley of the shadow of death --- That's Testing !!!
She will fear no evil --- That's Protection !!!
For Thou art with her --- That's Faithfulness !!!
Thy rod and Thy staff they comfort her --- That's Discipline !!!
Thou preparest a table before Terri in the presence of her enemies--- That's Hope !!!
Thou annointest her head with oil --- That's Consecration !!!
Her cup runneth over --- That's Abundance !!!
Surely goodness and mercy shall follow Terri all the days of her life --- That's Blessing !!!
And she will dwell in the house of the Lord --- That's Security!!!
Forever --- That's Eternity !!!
.
You think Cranford, who misdiagnoses people as PVS, is unbiased? I don't. He can't even speak straight.
I just hope there is a heaven and a hell.
Thanks for that Dr Mary, but the patient expired at 9:5 AM.
Judge Greer wouldn't have listened to you anyway.
...and no definitive measures of brain function, eg PET.
Sheesh, just simply to have gotten her out of her room, as michael USED to do in early 90's . . . Lord, may the truth finally, finally come out, in whatever way You choose.
In this day of readily available info and medical advances, I am appalled at the lack of info allowed in deciding this case.
all you have to do is to have your own eyes to see the videos and the original medical records that accidently got through michael's tight embargo on medical info.
....for class.
Murder 1. Definitely premeditated.
The "credible" doctor who posted his opinions on a blog - can you tell me the doctor's name? Credentials?
As for the docs, I don't really care about their personal views - I'll tend to believe a doctor who will tell me his name over one who will not.
I was just thinking Terri will be walking in Heaven soon with Mother Teresa and the Pope. It will be a grand reunion! There will be much celebrating in Heaven!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.