Skip to comments.Smoke and Mirrors [Ken Miller on Dover, Pt. 2]
Posted on 01/03/2009 11:08:51 AM PST by Coyoteman
In Part 1, I showed that Casey Luskins charges with respect to my testimony in Kitzmiller v. Dover were completely false. Michael Behe did indeed argue, throughout his 1996 book, Darwins Black Box, that the entire blood-clotting system was irreducibly complex, and I cited examples from that book to prove it. Therefore, the existence of a living organism missing so much as a single part of that system was indeed a falsification of IDs blood-clotting argument. Given that we now have examples of organisms (jawless fish) missing at least 5 components of that irreducibly complex system, its perfectly obvious that Luskins attempts to rehabilitate that argument are hopeless.
Ever the optimist, Part 2 of Luskins end-of-year project is to salvage Of Pandas and People, the creationist-turned-ID textbook that was at the heart of the Dover trial. Incredibly, in trying to accomplish this feat, he fails to understand the very argument hes trying to prop up. What Luskin does not seem comprehend is that irreducible complexity is not an argument for design it is an argument against evolution. Simply stated, when a system is labeled as irreducibly complex, the ID proponent is making a claim for the unevolvability of that system. The reason that such systems are said to be unevolvable is because their individual parts are supposedly nonfunctional until they are all combined into a single, working system. As Behe has said and written, any irreducibly complex system that is missing a part is by definition nonfunctional. As Behe further points out, since those parts are nonfunctional on their own, they could not have been assembled by evolution, because natural selection can only choose systems that are already working
That would be a powerful argument against evolution if it were true. Unfortunately, its not...
(Excerpt) Read more at blogs.discovermagazine.com ...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.