[RGirard]

Poll is open - have fun!

[Perdogg]

Carrie looks better in a bikini

[frogjerk]

Currently:

Carrie Underwood .1%
Kelly Clarkson .2%
Barak Obami 99.7%

[ilgipper]

I think Carrie has passed Kelly up at this point. Kelly has an amazing voice, no doubt. Probably more talented voice-wise. Carrie has driven to the top of the industry. She is one of the biggest stars in music these days. I would put Daughtry up there, too. All three have had huge commercial success. To bad Adam had to start out the way he did. He really turned off a good part of the audience with that move.

[KansasGirl]

Carrie Underwood by far.

[SnakeDoctor]

Underwood, and it isn’t even close. I’d likely put Daughtry well above Clarkson, too. Clarkson seems to have been a bit of a one-hit wonder.

SnakeDoc

[DecoyJames]

Who Cares???

Paula Abdul has had more #1 hits than all Idol alumni combined. lol

[GulfBreeze]

Ok, I and 18 other people have voted!

Thanks

[albie]

I like this quote from Underwood...

On releasing “Jesus, Take the Wheel”: “People started saying, Oh, it’s kind of risky. You’re coming out with a religious song. And I was thinking, Really? I grew up in Oklahoma, I always had a close relationship with God. I never thought it was risky in the least. If anything, I thought it was the safest thing I could do.”

[VanDeKoik]

Sanjaya Malakar

Only reason I ever watched the show.

[JPG]

Kelly.

[Bad Jack Bauer]

They were basically even in all things until I was reminded that Kelly made that horrid movie with Justin. I felt that she had to pay for that and so I voted for Carrie.

[pepsi_junkie]

Some questions can never be answered. How many angels can dance on the head of a pin? Who would win in a fight, hulk or Superman? How many grizzly bears has Sarah Palin personally strangled? Unanswerable!

[napscoordinator]

That is tough!!! I think both have magnificent morals. Carrie would look better in a bathing suit but the question is who is the great American Idol. I hope they have a tie choice. I must go see the question and answers given.

[napscoordinator]

Ok...no tie vote. I voted for Kelly because I knew she would be the underdog. I sincerely think both are good Christian women.

[lesko]

Herein lies the problem - too much attention paid to this stupid American Idol show while our elected continue to ramrod our country.

[kalee]

No contest, Underwood has sung with Nancy and Annie.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UQ7ZmaL2480

[Phlap]

Anyone who would care needs to get out more.

Although ...

The two together could be a ten. lol

[Tijeras_Slim]

Carrie Underwood vs. Kelly Clarkson, who is the greater American Idol?

Are the contents measured by weight or volume?

[Seruzawa]

Who are Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood? Did they learn their chops with John Mayall?

[vetvetdoug]

I vote for Sam the Sham and the Pharaohs.