**THE 2009-10 BCS National Championship Game Live Thread**

[GOP_Raider]

I did, I’m going to have to read it this summer when I’m done with the Shelby Foote Civil War trilogy.

[TejasRose]

I don’t know if I’m reading your post correctly....are you suggesting that Colt McCoy was not really hurt but was taken out of the game for other purposes?

[txhurl]

18 is mighty young to jump in and lead 22-23 year old seniors to a national championship while 275 pounders or bigger are trying to kill ya

---

That is a good point that people need to understand. Like Jeff Ward mentioned today, SEC players are big guys who prefer meat grinder results to style points.

We’re lucky they didn’t mangle Gilbert while they had the chance.

[WhyisaTexasgirlinPA]

Well he’s running as a Republican - not sure if he could win or not, but seriously doubt anyone in West Texas or current Texas Tech fans would vote for him....so we could lose the seat to a liberal puke. Let’s hope he doesn’t get any further than campaigning in Jim Sowell’s living room in Dallas

[Impy]

Boise will likely be ranked second.

Or maybe 4th cause BCS sucks ***.

[They'reGone2000]

Thanks for all of the threads.

Hope we're all still here in ten years when Joe Paterno decides to retire.

[yellowhammer]

This game was a triumph of conservatism over liberalism

[Freedom of Speech Wins]

Suggesting that this may be a possibility, yes.

Guy's last game before signing a pro contract too. They might be a little more cautious as a result of that.

The hit Rothlisberger took in a game recently looked much worse and Rothlisberger came right back out.

We saw McCoy move his arm when he clapped after getting hit and he didn't look hurt. So he was capable of moving the arm. We don't see him even try to make a throwing motion with the arm. So his claim of not being able to feel the arm doesn't seem to standup as he was able to move it immediately after being hit.

When you watch the video I linked to my original post here on this you can see that he moves his throwing arm after the hit.

If he can move the arm ok, why wouldn't he play is the question.

We can see him moving the arm after the hit.

Other than that he didn't try to move it that I can see. Why doesn't he at least try to move it again?

[Freedom of Speech Wins]

Richard Kimball's post describes what the injury may have been pretty well, so he could very well have been hurt. The nerve damage possibility explanation sounds like a reason not to play. He moved the arm after the hit so he could move the arm though. Just don't understand the injury, but I know I am not a doctor.

Anything not impossible I view as a possibility.

[crusty old prospector]

Has anyone seen this? Several more here. Coming soon to a Dollar General near you.

http://bustersports.com/blog/buster-blog/2010/01/10/alabama-displays-national-championship-trophy-at-walmart-photos/

<

[TejasRose]

His arm had no feeling (i.e., nerve damage). It was not paralyzed...he could move it. He tried to throw the ball while he was in the locker room to his Dad and had no control over where the ball went. So, a quarterback with no control of the ball would be of very little good in the game. The team doctors and trainers did not clear him to go back into the game. People can speculate all they want to.