The best singer and a beautiful. But she lacked the spark that makes a star. I noted this a month ago. And if a non-expert such as myself saw it, then it was pretty obvious.
Singing talent is not enough to make it in the pop music industry. You need the whole act, the moves.
For you American Idol Fans out there, here’s my theory...
Pia Toscano is from NEW YORK CITY. NEW YORKERS WATCH, BUT DON’T USUALLY GET OFF THEIR BUTTS TO VOTE.
Take note of the past winners -— Kelly Clarkson (Texas), Ruben Studdard (Alabama), Fantasia ( North Carolina ), Carrie Underwood ( Oklahoma ), Taylor Hicks ( Alabama ), Jordin Sparks ( Arizona ), David Cook ( Kansas City, Missouri), Kris Allen (Arkansas)....
See anything in common ? THEY’RE ALL FROM RED STATES !!
The show is more a voting competition, not just a singing competition.
Thia was one of my favorites. I think she has such a beautiful, special voice and I hope she can develop the other qualities to advance her career. She just doesn’t have the stage presence or enough outward confidence yet. But she’s only 15!
I agree. The one thing the bottom three had in common was they were all good singers but charisma deficient. It’s funny how the judges are saying they are all really good, but shocked when one of them goes home. Really? Someone has to go home every week. Which of the other ones that they priased would they want to leave instead?
It is a vital component. Seems obvious yet still there are some that do not show being real and into what they are singing. The voices are great this time. It is the total package plus likability that usually wins in the end.