Posted on 04/10/2011 1:33:26 PM PDT by mainestategop
In the 1700s, the courtesans of Queen Catherine of Russia gave her tours along the Volga river where she witnessed a happy and thriving bourgeoisie living in clean and prosperous villages. But this was all a show to cover disease, poverty, and misery that lay just behind the facade that had been erected for her benefit.
This is the origin of the phrase Potemkin Village, a place where a politically generated appearance covers a less impressive underside.
Europe is today filled with Potemkin Villages, none as successful as Denmark. Denmark is often cited as an exemplary country within the EU, with an economic system that others should seek to emulate. In the comparisons of GDP per capita, Denmark ranks consistently in the top ten worldwide, and often in the top five.
Denmark's economic data for 2001 appear impressive:
•Slow but balanced growth of 1.1 percent, down from 3.2 percent in 2000. Denmark has had higher growth than many other EU countries since the mid-1990s. •An inflation rate of 2.3 percent. The inflation rate has not been above 3 percent since 1994 and not above 4 percent at all in the 1990s. •The long-term interest rate (10-year) has shown a steady decline from a level in 1990 of more than 10 per cent to today's of just around 5 percent. •The short-term interest rate (3-month) likewise has shown a steady and even bigger decline over the period. From 12 per cent in 1990 to just around 3.5 percent today. •An unemployment rate that is relatively low and falling. The rate is now officially 5.2 percent, down from 12.2 percent in 1993. •A budget surplus of 1.9 percent of GDP. It is the 5th year in a row that the budget has been in surplus. •A fairly large surplus on the current account of 3.4 percent of GDP. Denmark has had a surplus on the current account continuously in the 1990s, except for 1998. •The Danish public debt as a percentage of the GDP has fallen for several years and is now approximately 45 percent instead of close to 80 percent in the early 1990s. •The Danish foreign public debt as a percentage of the GDP is also falling and is now approximately 15 percent instead of almost 40 percent in the early 1990s. •Denmark is the least corrupt country in the world according to surveys that measure such things. •Denmark also claims to have a population with a very robust work ethic, which is probably true. All of this looks very good, at least on the surface. But let us look at some other economic statistics that are not mentioned nearly as often.
Denmark has an entire population of 5,350,000 people. Of them, 1,150,000 are below 18 years old. Of the remaining 4,200,000 people, 2,214,000 people receive government transfer payments (not counting 260,000 students that receive public scholarships of $550 per month).
When you recalculate these 2,214,000 people, of whom some receive only part-time government transfers, into people who live full-time on transfer income, the total becomes 1,590,000 people living off transfer payments.
Out of these 1,590,000 people, 710,000 are pensioners and the remaining approximately 900,000 are working-age people. Most of them cannot be found in the unemployment statistics. They are on other kinds of public transfer programs of which there exist ten different types.
There are approximately 1,900,000 people working in the private sector and 840,000 working in the public sector or publicly owned companies. (The reason the numbers do not add up to 4.2 million is because not all are full time workers.)
We can conclude from this that of the people in the working age of 18 to 66, more than one quarter live passively on government transfers (full time). For every 100 persons employed full time in 1999, there were 33 working-age people receiving support. Adding pensioners, the total number was 61 people on full time transfer income for each 100 full time employed persons. (The pensioners are financed by a pay-as-you-go pension scheme). And out of those who are employed, 31.5 percent work for the government.
All of this, of course, needs to be financed. Denmark has therefore for many years had a very high and continuously increasing tax level.
In 2002, the lowest marginal income tax level is 44.31 percent, then it increases to 49.77 percent and 63.33 percent. Forty percent of the working people pay the top marginal tax rate of 63.33 percent, which applies to all income over $33,000.
There are very few tax deductions available, and the tax value of the tax deductions is continuously being reduced.
A sales tax of 25 percent hits just about everything.
The capital gains tax is 59.7 percent for a private person in the high income tax bracket, unless you hold your investment for more than 3 years. It then falls to 44.8 percent.
There are additional taxes on "sinful" and "luxury" products likes cigarettes, alcohol, candy, soft drinks, electronic goods, and other luxuries.
For cars, there is a 180 percent special tax on top of the sales tax of 25 percent. Then there is a registration fee and a weight fee to be paid twice per year for the privilege of using the roads. The price of gasoline is nearly three times as high as it is in the US.
Denmark imposes many new green taxes. These are the taxes that have increased most substantially during the 1990s. These taxes hit heating, electricity, water, and gasoline.
Real estate, which is already heavily taxed, has been the target of new taxes throughout the 1990s. In addition, the tax value of deductions have been continuously reduced.
With Denmark, as with all of Europe, your perception of its economic status depends on which statistics you are looking at. Also, your judgement of its economic status depends on your preferences (is stability alone to be valued, or is freedom also important?) and your time horizon (does it matter that all these taxes make Denmark far less prosperous than it otherwise would be?).
Danish politicians proudly proclaims that Denmark is the most egalitarian country in the world. They may be right. The obsession with equality delivers a crushing, daily blow to anyone with a new idea or the inkling to cultivate an ability that surpasses the norm. Young people have virtually no chance to improve their lot in life, to take risks, to make it big through innovation and entrepreneurship.
Excellent and hard work are not rewarded by a system that systematically levels the population into a huge homogenous middle class, whose standard of living advances only incrementally and in ways that flout economic priorities. A total tax level that approaches 70 percent is a relentless and debilitating reminder that this country desires no personal economic achievement and no accumulation of wealth.
And yet many people seem to be happy with this system, somewhat like the masses of Huxley's Brave New World. Of course it sets up a dynamic that harms everyone in the long run, but people don't seem to understand or care about this. Equality and stability are regarded as more important than progress and freedom.
A heritage of honesty and hard work are marvelous tools for papering over the failures of welfarism and subtle servitude. With the right attitude, even a prison population can settle into a comfortable and egalitarian existence, one that might even impress Queen Catherine passing by on a boat. But lacking energy, enterprise, entrepreneurship, and freedom, such systems of economic control exact a huge toll with the passage of time.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Per Henrik Hansen works at Danmarks Nationalbank and teaches economics at the Copenhagen Business School. him M
The whole EU is nothing but a Potemkin village. Commmunists and libtards tout it everyday as a standard to follow. Yet to call it a homogenous middle class is a joke. In reality homogenous lower class is the end result. Just like in Russia and china and only a minor percentage will live a higher standard that STILL... STILLL will never match the prosperity that even America's middle class has.
This is just the beginning of course. Soon we shall see famine, political strife, genoicde and despotism. The EU is on its way to becoming the new USSR and end up the same way as it was.
Harrison Bergeron is in prison somewhere in Denmark.
WWBD?
What would Beowulf do?
Have you been to Denmark?
I have.
It is expensive, but it is far from being a dump like most of our liberal run cities in the United States.
I remember walking around Copenhagen and people left their expensive mountain bikes unlocked while they shopped.
No graffiti, no trash strewn everywhere, no sirens or ambulances, no gun shots from gangs.
I am not saying it was perfect, but their socialism is far better than the socialism we got in this country, and, yes, many of the liberal run cities in the US are socialist and have tax rates comparable to Europe, but without anybody benefiting except the overpaid liberal bureaucrats making 6 figures and the illegals on the dole, who are better off on welfare in this country than being a peon in theirs.
It’s not their socialism that accounts for low crime - it’s their homogeneity.
Denmark has their Mozzies.
Is it a race issue or are our liberals worthless and corrupt?
San Francisco doesn’t have much of a black population, but the taxes are high(comparable to Europe), it is highly bureaucratic, crime is out of control, the roads are horrible, the city is extemely dirty, and you have bums and degenerates everywhere.
You can live in a location where just about everyone is white, but you still see plenty of n*****s.
Other countries are less likely to have that ghetto culture, so they are more livable.
I know they don't like to talk about it much, but these differences ~ as minor as those of us outside that part of the world might think them to be ~ have been sufficient to create wars many times over the last few centuries.
There are libraries of books written about Danish psycho-social incompatibilities ~ and they paint a frightening picture.
Well, then it must be a American liberal cultural issue, because where I live, there is no black culture or black people or any ghettos, and the liberals have run my hometown right into the toilet.
But what we do have are high taxes and an overpaid bureaucracy with horrible services, schools, roads, graffiti, bums, degenerates etc.
Haven’t you ever heard to saying, “It’s easy for Sweden to be socialist, because everyone there is Swedish.”
An almost ten year old, factually out of date article about a country with a total population somewhere between that of Berlin and Paris. So that is pars pro toto for the whole of Europe?
Look! Some Dane put up a website just for you (don't forget to turn the sound on)! ;-)
If people can’t compete for money, they will compete for something else to get prestige. Writers, musicians, and artists....
The only wars that could fit this picture I remember are the Prussian-Danish Wars over Schleesvik-Holstein during the unification of Germany, and the Second World War. The border was afterwards fixed according to population majority of each area.
Like I said just one thing after the other.
“Courtesans”?
Doesn’t anybody pick up a dictionary any more?
That would be courtiers, she was more or less her own courtesan.
And the title was Tsarina or Empress, not Queen.
I wasn´t talking about the wars per se, I know the history of Europe and its various kingdoms, especially Danish, as we were part of it until our Independence in 1944. They stayed though completely out of WW1, despite a numerous Danish minority on the other side of the border. Something that was mostly fixed after the World War (the first one), by adjustment of the borders and population exchange.
But your other statements perplexed me. I haven´t heard them before and would like to hear what you mean, as there has for a long time understandably been a Love-Hate relationship between our two peoples.
please explain I’d like to know more.
Hey! it might be out of date but the EU is going down hill. all those nice perks you hear about? Nothing compared to what’s coming once the system crashes. Which it will.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.