Posted on 08/23/2011 5:05:54 PM PDT by nickcarraway
DD, you didn’t read the thread all that well or you’d know that’s the scenario the summary court martial crowd had in mind.
Like most of your posts...
a combination of bookish fantasy and nonsense.
driftdiver, don’t you know? Guard duty is a team sport played because there aren’t any nearby bars for drinking. It isn’t as though some pull the duty while others sleep. And in muawiyah-world, there are just tons of guys doing the guard duty, because they will all get a good sleep after their shift is over. Lots of redundancy! And exhaustion is something that only happens due to medical condition!
Unfortunately, the US military rarely gets to pull combat duty in muawiyah-world...
You need to keep your wits about you ~ if you don't you could fall asleep on guard, or worse, shoot somebody's sheep, or maybe a vole!
Sounds to me you have no idea what guard duty is about.
MD, if we sent guys home for falling asleep on guard duty, EVERYONE would fall asleep on guard duty!
If you reward bad behavior, you get more bad behavior.
really who has suggested summary court martial eg execution.
You don’t have a clue about combat duty, or how and why guard duty is pulled. You’re like a dog watching TV, and insisting on writing a review of the show...
He talks like a REMF if there ever was one.
Not that there is anything wrong with REMFs...but it is what it is...probably read a few “Concepts of Strategy” books though.
Clueless.
I’ve seen plenty of posts which only had one guy in them. I guess the other ones were taking a nap.
Something was wrong with him, that's for sure. If the report is true. To me, this is a suspicious story. I'm wondering if he wasn't unpopular for other reasons.
“I’m wondering if he wasn’t unpopular for other reasons. “
Very possible, the kind of guy who would let himself fall asleep while on duty probably has other issues which would make him unpopular among those trusting him with their lives.
They may do that. I got to see them on guard duty ~ and they drank an awful lot of booze. They'd be tossing bottles all night onto the mine field.
It's possible I served more guard duty on the West German/GDR and West German/Czech border than the combined lot of you served anywhere combined.
Quite frankly you people are a pitiful lot tonight. Your lack of training in the finer and more subtle nuances of armed guard (and lookout for the less formal situations) is incredibly obvious.
And no, we don't do summary executions. That statement that begins with the penalties and concludes "as a Court Martial may direct" means TRIAL FIRST, PUNISHMENT LATER.
“But the sniveling twerp showed them !!”
Classy!
21 isn't a child, granny and it's spelled Corps.
awww mailman, don’t let it get to you
People didn’t fall asleep on duty when I was in. But then I only had 3 years where it really mattered.
When someone screwed up they faced the consequences, they didn’t whine about a medical condition or go cryin for their momma. If they did there wasn’t any sympathy.
the "too lazy" part of your statement assumes facts not in evidence.
When I was a hospital chaplain working pediatrics, we had a very sweet 7 year old girl whose brain was being crowded into dysfunction by a large and inoperable "benign" tumor. She was dying and nothing was working.
the first sign of the tumor was an absence seizure or something of the kind. Her parent's response? They gave her a spanking.
You can imagine what they were going through. And, forgive me, but you deserve to go through something similar. Until you are the world's foremost expert on the neuro-psychology of sleep, I'd recommend considering that you just might not have enough facts to judge someone as being lazy, as those parents didn't have enough facts when they jumped to the conclusion that their own child, who needed their love and understanding, was rude rather than ill.
Sad. RIP.
So you use a child to compare to this marine? Are you MAD!!!??
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.