Posted on 03/15/2013 1:41:01 PM PDT by BruceDeitrickPrice
Philosophers always say, define your terms. So what is a quack?
Quacks are people who treat any one idea (it may be a bad idea or a good idea) as if it is the entire world.
Excess is the problem. A lack of proportion is what makes someone a quack, and what makes quacks a menace.
There are poisons which, used in tiny doses, can be beneficial. It’s the dose that makes the poison. Quacks would not understand that. If a few drops are good, they would say, let’s make everyone swim in the stuff.
Quackery lies in treating some particular answer as THE answer, as if someone settled on spinach as the perfect food and outlawed all other vegetables.
In a complex world, however, we need complex, nuanced answers. These will invariably consist of many interlocking answers. Only a quack would say, no, we need only THIS answer.
Public schools are practically defined by a tsunami of quackery. Every idea pushed in the public schools is pushed to the point of pathology. Once the Education Establishment swings behind an idea, they think it is their job to destroy all other ideas, to force every student to accept this one idea uber alles.
There was a 70-year period when the Education Establishment actually outlawed teaching the alphabet. According to Whole Word, children were to memorize the shapes of words, and not try to learn the letters or their sounds. The prevailing orthodoxy today is a mix of various methods, so some people may have forgotten just how irrational our public schools were pre-1999. Whole Word, which is pure quackery, is a paradigm of everything wrong in the public schools, and in modern pedagogy. (NB: the new version, usually called Balanced Literacy, is an improvement but is still only halfway back to non-quackery.)
Here’s another illustration of knowing no limits. A popular instructional method called Constructivism might, in small doses, be a plus. But our public schools seem incapable of subtlety. Having embraced Constructivism, schools tend to declare that all direct teaching is evil. Suddenly we’re in this bizarre other-world where the only valid knowledge is that which the students ferret out for themselves. That can be a long slow process. Direct instruction, where teachers actually teach what they believe needs to be taught, is the quick road to mastery. Constructivism is the slow road to not knowing what the heck you’re talking about.
Public schools are a microcosm of the broader political landscape. Every “liberal” idea is now embraced as though it is a religion unto itself. There are people at the ACLU who will argue that each alleged right is supreme and cannot be qualified in any way.
So we can’t just have a little improvement here, a little improvement there. No, that’s evil because it’s partial. So we listen to a woman who says, “Intercourse is the pure, sterile, formal expression of men's contempt for women." Well, that’s an English sentence, but so is “Flowers can discuss the Roman Empire.” Surely that couldn’t be the ravings of a quack. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea_Dworkin)
The worst of it is that the far-left has always used minorities and the disadvantaged in a manipulative way. It’s never clear that liberals actually care about the people they claim to speak for. Rather they use these “oppressed” people as levers to seize more control. If the Education Establishment actually cared about disadvantaged kids, they would make sure those kids learn to read in the first grade. But they don’t do this. So we know what’s in their hearts.
Do you think Stalin cared about black people? Unlikely. But he tried to meddle in American racial politics, pushing the Comintern at its Sixth World Congress in 1928 to adopt a resolution affirming the presence of a black nation in the American South. Stalin said they had the right to secede. How convenient. Stalin, of course, was a clever tactician of trouble, and a brilliant community organizer who never let a crisis go to waste. (http://return2source.wordpress.com/2012/06/24/nations-want-liberation-the-black-belt-nation-in-the-21st-century/)
Public schools are now full of cries that they will teach critical thinking. Schools were teaching critical thinking for millennia but nobody thought to mention the obvious. Now that they mention it all the time, you can be sure that critical thinking is on life support. Had we critical thinkers, quacks would not run public education. Had we critical thinkers, we wouldn’t hear so much praise for Common Core Curriculum, Reform Math, and other monstrosities.
For the Greeks, balance and proportion were the essence of philosophy. Reason was a tool for finding the Golden Mean. We needed to locate our proper dominion between extremes, between heaven and hell. Subtlety is required. Quacks would not understand any of this.
I’d like to suggest it’s good to be a Don Quixote now and then, and tilt with all the silly windmills. Call them what they are, antisocial quackery.
Maybe now and then it’s helpful to state the obvious. A little of some things is a good idea. A lot of those same things is a force for destruction.
-----------
Bruce Deitrick Price/Improve-Education.org
It's fair to point out that the Don was the ultimate in quackery by this definition.
My 15 year old son just started this semester with k12/Wava (Washington Virtual Academy) and is doing MUCH better. No distractions from other kids, no progressive sermons from whiny ass teachers who can’t handle their jobs, etc. He LOVES being able to stay at home and do his school work. We are within walking distance of the high school, so he still gets to see his friends, without having to deal with all the other crap that goes on at school. What’s cool is his friends can come over after school for a couple hours, and then catch the activity bus home. I have to make sure to stay on top of what he’s doing (I’m his ‘learning coach’), but overall, it’s working well. It’s worth it!
Public schools are a waste of money. Shut them down. Think of how much money would be saved. Think of the quality private schools that could replace them.
I got yelled at by a smarmy teacher when my spelling (whole word crap) was atrocious, she said JUST MEMORIZE IT! Pretty hard when you had wicked ADD! (That is NOT BS, BTW...)
Good for you! Public schools are child abuse, IMHO.
True, but he did it with personality, and personality goes a long way :)
Are you **finally** “getting it”?
Our nation's government owned and run K-12 schools are the archetypical socialist-funded, single-payer. GODLESS, and price-fixed monopoly cartel.
When in the history of humankind has it ever been possible to reform a socialist-funded, single-payer, GODLESS, and price-fixed monopoly cartel?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.