When I see Urban, I don’t see him as McCoy... I see him as Gary Mitchell. Quinto comes close to capturing the look, but it’s soulless. The rest look and act nothing like the characters. Zoe Saldana is hot, but she doesn’t look or act anything like Uhura. Gabourey Sidibe probably would’ve done no worse, and at least doesn’t look like a space cheerleader.
As for the rest, my opinion of Faux Trek is unchanged.
They’re not supposed to be the same, new actor, new times, they’re supposed to do their thing. Again look at all the different Bonds, the only two that are at all alike are Dalton and Brosnan and that’s because Dalton built his entire career on being a poor man’s version of Brosnan.
It’s your opinion, but it’s not faux is real. It’s closer to TOS and more entertaining than anything they’ve done since TNG started.