Posted on 09/28/2023 11:55:39 AM PDT by ShadowAce
The Raspberry Pi 5 arrives in October with both a leap in performance and an incremental price rise. But will you be able to get your hands on one?
Originally aimed at hobbyists and educators, the Raspberry Pi has evolved into a serious bit of kit over the years despite its diminutive size. The latest generation has continued that evolution into a machine that can chew through most productivity workloads while retaining many of the expansion options beloved by its customers.
However, elements have also been dropped, and the architecture remains more evolutionary than revolutionary.
First, the good news. Performance is impressive when compared to previous generations. According to the Raspberry Pi team, the device, which features a 64-bit quad-core Arm Cortex-A76 processor running at 2.4GHz, represents a 2-3x increase in CPU performance compared to the Raspberry Pi 4.
The graphics are also improved thanks to an 800MHz VideoCore VII GPU. Sure, it won't set racing the hearts of users more used to exotic Nvidia kit, but it does make for a decidedly smoother experience otherwise.
Also swifter is storage thanks to support for the high-speed SDR104 mode, meaning a potential doubling of peak SD card performance – but you'll need to make sure you buy the right SD card to use it. A single-lane PCI Express 2.0 interface is also available, although you'll need an adapter.
Another notable improvement is the inclusion of a real-time clock, but you will have to provide your own battery solution. This is a boon for customers needing to run disconnected for long periods, although third-party options are available for previous generations if needed.
The team said: "For the first time, this is a full-size Raspberry Pi computer using silicon built in-house at Raspberry Pi."
Indeed, there has been somewhat of a step change in performance; even the dedicated two-lane MIPI camera and display interfaces of the past are now replaced by a pair of four-lane 1.5Gbps MIPI transceivers.
However, there is some bad news to stir into the pot. The audio and composite jack has been ditched. According to Pi supremo, Eben Upton, this was due to space constraints on the board. As for what users requiring composite functionality should do, Upton told us: "For composite video, you can see there is a pair of 0.1" pads on the bottom edge."
The news is less good for fans of audio from the deleted jack. He went on: "There's isn't a recommended solution for audio, other than to use either a USB audio device or HAT."
The price has also increased slightly – $60 for the 4GB version and $80 for the 8GB incarnation – and RISC-V is conspicuous by its absence. You'll also need to invest in a new case – the ports have been moved – and the Pi 5 has no cooling tech out of the box.
Upton put the price uplift down to a slight increase in manufacturing cost and a general rise in component prices – other than SDRAM.
The lack of cooling will raise an eyebrow or two, considering how warm the Pi 4 tended to get. The previous generation could be run without a cooling solution, yet sometimes the CPU temperature would soar and hit performance.
Although our review sample came with a separate cooler and fan, the Pi 5 appears to have improved matters temperature-wise. In an admittedly subjective test that involved hammering the hardware with s-tui, stress and firing up a few productivity applications, the CPU temperature climbed to just over 80˚C but went no higher.
Upton said this was due to the updated architecture. He told The Register: "BCM2712 is on 16FFC, so definitely a big improvement in specific energy versus the 28HPC we used for BCM2711. Cortex A76 reputedly has better energy per instruction iso-process, so those two things stack together to give quite a significant improvement for a given workload.
"Which we then more than spend, in terms of peak power, by being able to do a lot more stuff."
Upton also noted that he tended to run the hardware without active cooling.
Users of the Pi 4 will also remember the aggravation around USB-C power. Lessons appear to have been learned, and Upton told us that the diminutive computer was subject to intensive testing. It will, however, be interesting to see what happens this time when the hardware – which has increased in complexity – hits the wider community. Upton said 100,000 units should be available at launch - scheduled by the end of October - with more to hit the channel in subsequent months.
He said the Pi 4 was "back in a decent stock position," although we've found tracking down all varieties still tricky. He said the pipeline – components and manufacturing – would be good for "roughly" one million units by the end of January.
According to Upton, the balance of the two configurations available has "probably" shifted slightly toward the 8GB variety. The combination presents some intriguing possibilities. The Raspberry Pi OS – now based on Debian "Bookworm" – has been sprayed with updates to handle the hardware changes, although users of the Pi 4 will also see benefits. Some enterprising users have also managed to get other operating systems running on previous generations – most notably Windows on Arm.
The RPi 4 model B alongside our review sample of the Raspberry Pi 5
While Microsoft has yet to officially support efforts to get Windows 11 working on the device, Upton praised the enthusiasts who had coaxed the software giant's flagship operating system to life on the platform. The additional horsepower available on the Pi 5 could change the experience from being a novelty for hobbyists to something more usable.
Upton said: "It's been impressive to see people getting Windows up and running. Lots of very ingenious stuff going on there."
As for official support, he said: "That would be a question for Microsoft: we'll certainly support them if they're interested. Historically the issue with 'real' Windows support on Raspberry Pi has been a lack of DirectX drivers."
Implementing DirectX on top of Vulkan would be immensely beneficial, considering the recent investments made by the Pi team.
Some omissions will also vex users, particularly those hopeful of a RISC-V implementation.
Upton told The Register that little consideration had been given to the architecture this time around, noting issues around maturity in the software stack and a lack of "competitive" licensable cores as factors. He said: "A new architecture has to overcome significant barriers to gain acceptance."
However, he also said: "Never say never."
After a week of using the device as a primary computer, we can confirm that the extra performance is most welcome. Yes, we've not been brave enough to run things for any length of time without a cooler, no matter what Upton says – call it Pi 4 PTSD. That said, if you need one, then a cooler is unlikely to break the bank.
As far as stability is concerned, during the time we've had with the review sample we've experienced one occasion where the device froze and required a hard reset. We'll monitor this over the coming weeks and report back if this reoccurs. Otherwise, the Pi 5 put up with the day-to-day abuse of being the primary computer with aplomb.
Getting another case is irritating, although this hack at least has enough Lego in the house to deal with the issue. The price increase might also irk as the Pi 5 is now quite some way from what the first iterations cost. While it can be excused thanks to other improvements, the device is not quite the bargain it once was, which might put off impulse buyers.
Overall, the Pi has evolved into a very useable computer. Upton told us the next generation Compute Module should be along in 2024 but wouldn't comment on other form factors. Updating the Pi-400 hardware would undoubtedly make for some intriguing possibilities and Upton noted that storage speeds in future versions might be further increased through the use of SD Express, "but that standard didn't mature in time for this generation."
And with the European Space Agency having recently updated its Raspberry Pis on the International Space Station – and more hardware due to arrive later this year – could we see a Pi on the Moon before long?
"No comment." ®
I might steal that tag line to tick off some co-workers.
I read about this earlier, but I don’t see a lot of use for it.
on the other hand I do want another Pi zero 2
I have been watching rpilocator.com for months and cannot find one in the usa.
the pi zero 2 makes a great music streamer, and if you use a pi zero 3 you can have a music server/streamer combo.
I use volumio on my pi zero2 and picoreplayer with logitech media server on my pi 3.
don’t know what I would use a pi 5 for
Gaming....................
Gambling..................
Pr0n.....................
I have a couple of Raspberry Pi 4s, one is gathering ADS-B data and sending to Flightaware, my antenna is not in the greatest position but it’s the best I can do where I live without getting on top of the house, which I’m not about to considering it’s a 2-story house.
The other is primarily a back up to the first one and I install TOR on it and perused the dark web a little until I saw some of the crap out there and realized it’s not a safe place that I wanted to be in.
put it in a case, attach a keyboard, mouse, and 2x HDMI displays and you have a smooth running linux box
games. video. plex server. etc
Most people have no idea about the dark web. It is truly disturbing. That said, I see it as a place conservatives may need to leverage at some point. We won’t be able to organize using traditional methods.
It’s definitely the wild wild west on the dark web, in just a few hours you could supposedly buy any illegal drug imaginable, guns and assorted other nasty things.
I know TOR and the Dark Web are supposed to be untraceable, but I didn’t want to be anywhere near that type of thing.
Plus, I don’t own or really know how to use Bitcoin, which seemed to be required to pay for things.
Yeah...it makes you feel dirty just being there.
This is a pretty decent little board, but it’s probably a little too power hungry for my needs. I prefer the ESP32.
Sounds good, but I will wait until the ecosystem solidifies. I am disappointed that the footprint has changed - again. I was hoping to get an upgrade for my CrowPi, but I guess it is not to be.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.