[Dog Gone]

Suppose her health is affected by his cologne. Does she have the right to get an injunction against him?

Where does this end? How far do your property rights extend beyond your property?

[Skip Ripley]

She rents, he owns. She's already accepted limitations from the owners of her unit on where she can smoke by agreeing not to smoke indoors. I'll bet she is instructed by the court to smoke a specified distance from the neighbor's door.

[TASMANIANRED]

"Dogs and cats"

She needs to file a countersuit about the offense of the smell of dog poop lingering on the air for 4 hrs after the poop pick up. Also cat poop is loaded with shedded virus, CMV at the top of the list.

[templar]

Where does this end? How far do your property rights extend beyond your property?

So you would be siding with Zangrando for protecting his own property rights against intrusion by Kuder's activities (which, apparently, are currently extending into Zangrando's property)?

[Major_Risktaker]

"It hits you right away, the minute you walk out the door. It catches me, I start coughing, I know she's smoking, I can see she's smoking visually, and I can get the effects of the smoke when I inhale what should be fresh air in my own back patio,'' Zangrando told the judge."

If I was the Judge this would be my answer to Zangrando.
"Buy a fan and blow the smoke back.
Case Dismissed!"

[Paved Paradise]

There is a HUGE difference between allergies to perfumes/colognes (which I do have) and being subjected to inhaling toxins from cigarettes, which can cause major lung and or other respiratory problems. My allergies can make me sick (throw up), light headed and nauseated, but smoke can KILL - someday go check in on someone who has COPD and see if you want to get that.

You smokers are the militant ones.