Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Survivors Mark Buchenwald Anniversary
Guardian / AP ^ | 4/10/05 | TONY CZUCZKA

Posted on 04/10/2005 2:23:42 PM PDT by Valin

WEIMAR, Germany (AP) - Elderly survivors of the Buchenwald concentration camp laid flowers Sunday and observed a moment of silence for victims of the Nazis, 60 years after U.S. troops liberated the camp.

Flags from some 30 nations hung in a cold drizzle to symbolize the nations from which the camp's 240,000 prisoners came between 1937 and 1945. About 56,000 died - worked to death, shot or killed in medical experiments.

German Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder and U.S. veterans came to the camp memorial outside Weimar for the commemoration, which kindled vivid memories for the survivors, most of them in their 70s and 80s.

Georg Sterner, a Hungarian Jew, recalled looking out from Barracks No. 37 when the first U.S. tank crashed through the barbed-wire perimeter fence on the morning of April 11, 1945.

``We were hanging out of the windows,'' said Sterner, who was 17 then. ``It came slowly, slowly. It stopped between the trees. It revved the engine ... made a lunge, and broke through.''

Inside, shocked soldiers from the U.S 3rd Army found some 21,000 starving survivors and piles of corpses, some only partially burned in the crematorium ovens as the Nazi SS and their helpers fled the camp.

``It was so incredible - stacks of bodies, the smell, the total shock and confusion, people walking around by the thousands,'' said Jerry Hontas, who arrived the next day as a 21-year-old Army medic.

``We were so shocked we couldn't talk to each other for days,'' said Hontas, of Boca Raton, Fla. ``We had no concept of this kind of insane cruelty.''

On Sunday, some survivors came in wheelchairs. Others wore replicas of their striped inmate's uniforms and their old prisoner numbers.

Schroeder recalled that Weimar stands for Germany's classical cultural heritage - Johann Wolfgang Goethe, the most revered German author and playwright, had his home there - and said the Nazis had turned it into ``coldness and cruelty.''

``I bow before you, the victims and their families,'' he said at Weimar National Theater, addressing Buchenwald survivors in the audience.

Unlike Auschwitz, Buchenwald was not expressly built for mass killing, but the camp was just as much part of the Nazis' effort to wipe out anyone deemed un-German.

Sunday's ceremony was meant as a remembrance of victims of Nazi camps in Germany, which were successively freed as Allied troops advanced before the Nazi surrender in World War II in May 1945.

Thuringia, the state where Weimar is located, was a Nazi Party bastion even before Adolf Hitler came to power in 1933 and he often visited the city.

With an eye on recent electoral successes by Germany's extreme-right fringe, Schroeder said Germany must remain vigilant against racism and anti-Semitism.

``We remember what happened, and we remind others of it, because we must not forget,'' Thuringia governor Dieter Althaus said at the theater. ``Because if we forget, we risk that it will repeat itself.''

Buchenwald was part of the Nazi Holocaust in which 6 million European Jews died. But there also were non-Jewish victims - political prisoners from Germany and other European countries, Soviet prisoners of war and Jehovah's Witnesses among many others.

As Nazi control dissolved in April 1945, Buchenwald inmates rose up and took revenge on their captors just before the Americans came.

``One of the first things I saw was bodies hanging in the trees, because the inmates had captured some of the guards,'' said Jack Garwood, now a retired engineer in Naples, Fla., who was among the first soldiers to arrive.

The Americans brought Weimar residents to the site to see what happened just 5 miles from their town.

``They were very stoic, very unemotional,'' Hontas recalled. ``I remember only one woman dabbing her eyes.''

After the war, the site came under Soviet control. The Soviets imprisoned suspected Nazis and others under appalling conditions that claimed some 7,000 lives - a fact Schroeder noted on Sunday.


TOPICS: Germany; Miscellaneous
KEYWORDS: anniversary; buchenwald; holocaust; survivors; wwii

1 posted on 04/10/2005 2:23:45 PM PDT by Valin
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: Valin
Personal timing of this is scary, I just began rereading "Man's Search for Meaning" By Victor Frankl

If you haven't read it, I suggest getting a copy, usually found at any reseller or used shop for pretty cheap.

I do hope we never forget this chapter in history (or we will be doomed to repeat it) and I am amazed at the stark contrast in the treatment of this subject vs. Abu Grahib...We are not abusing prisoners, truly objective people will realize what true prisoner abuse is.
2 posted on 04/10/2005 2:36:05 PM PDT by King_Corey
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Valin

You can read the "The International Military Tribunal
Nuremberg" online at http://www.nizkor.org/
Dedicated to 12 million Holocaust victims who suffered and died at the hands of Adolf Hitler and his Nazi regime.


3 posted on 04/10/2005 2:45:37 PM PDT by FreeRep
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Valin
It is not forgotten. We must always be aware of man's inhumanity to man.

AND this horrible behavior should not be diminished by those on the left who casually equate their political opponents with Adolf Hitler. Doing so displays their own inhumanity and ignorance.
4 posted on 04/10/2005 2:51:52 PM PDT by ChildOfThe60s (If you can remember the 60's.....you weren't really there.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Valin
After the war, the site came under Soviet control. The Soviets imprisoned suspected Nazis and others under appalling conditions that claimed some 7,000 lives - a fact Schroeder noted on Sunday.

Those others were members of the non-communist opposition, many of whom had been imprisoned at the same camp by the Nazis. If you do the math, the death rate really wasn't that much different under the (International) Socialists than it had been under their fellow (National) Socialists.

5 posted on 04/10/2005 4:28:34 PM PDT by PAR35
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: PAR35

If you do the math, the death rate really wasn't that much different under the (International) Socialists than it had been under their fellow (National) Socialists.


Not really much difference between the two.


6 posted on 04/10/2005 4:57:41 PM PDT by Valin (The Problem with Reality is the lack of background music)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: Valin
Not to hijack your post, but here is something along those lines that I came across in a Kazakhstani journal. Excuse the bad translation:

She knows her only by name

The story of Karaganda resident Valentina Grigor'evna Mikhno, who was born in a German concentration camp in 1945, is similar to a scene from a Soviet war film, but with a very touching ending. An ending which in a real life has yet to be. Still, Valentina hopes and waits for it. Through the television program Zhdi menya ("wait for me"), the Karaganda resident is searching for a female Soviet spy who was working right under the very noses of the Germans. She wants to meet her so that she could bow low before the person who helped a newborn girl survive German captivity..


Valentina's mother Maria died in 1996. But long ago in 1941 the still young 'Masha' worked as a telephone operator in her home town of Lubna in the Poltava district in the Ukraine.

"Mama was the first to find out that the war had begun," Valentina quietly says. "On the 22nd of June she was working on the telegraph and received a message for the district party committee. On that very day they took mama to the front. She didn't even get to say goodbye to her parents."

Maria met her future husband Grisha after a few months in Kuybyshev. A real-life field romance bloomed between the young lieutenant and the communications specialist. "By 1944 our soldiers had already pushed back the Germans," Valentina explains. "All this time my parents never separated. They served together. Father was the commander of an observation post, and was also a comunications specialist, while mama was already pregnant with me. They offered to send her home, but she refused: 'Why? Victory is close'. But on the 20th of August mama was captured by the Germans."

The most frightening day "In the unit where mama served there were three Marias: Mikhno, Lomakina, and Kulikova," Valentina says. "And two of them were captured, it happened below Riga at the battle for Koenigsberg."

From the book Sources of courage, by a soldier from Maria Mikhno's unit, Ivan Vyborniy, who included the comm specialist's narration of her capture:

... on 20 August 1944 tanks broke through in the Tukums region. I was on duty at the switchboard. Suddenly Lomakina ran in, pale, shaking from fear. 'Fascists!' she yelled. 'Run to the woods!' I was already worried. Something had fallen on the comms line and I wasn't getting any messages. When Lomakina ran in, we knew what was up. They cut the wires! It was already too late to run. What could we do? 'Into the hay!' someone yelled...
"Father yelled that," Valentina tells us. "Three army pals: mama, Lomakina, and Kulikova quickly changed into civilian clothes. They ate their party membership cards and buried the covers in the bomb shelter. And somehow made it to the haystacks. Kulikova climbed into the hay, but mama was undecided. She was afraid that the Germans would poke the hay with their bayonets and kill me. And so, together with Lomakina, they ran into the woods. Lomakina didn't desert the pregnant woman, so that's why I consider her my second mother. But they couldn't make it very far - a German grabbed her by the hair: 'Haende Hoch!'."

Maria Mikhno's recollections from the book Sources of Courage:

They began the interrogations. What units, they asked, where are they located. The interrogations continued on the second and third day. And so we lived: from the cell to interrogation, from interrogation back to the cell. The fascists tried everything to get us to talk, tortured us with thirst and hunger. They made us put on wooden shoes that had nails projecting inside, and run in a circle. They thought that it would make us more talkative. No dice! We made it through this torture.
On the walls of the torture cells in the Riga prison the girls - in their own blood - wrote to their soldiers. The text of one such appeal was later written down by a platoon leader and sent to the commander of the 51st Army:
Dear friends! The little Hitlers wanted to find out from us comms girls our unit designations. After torture they threw us all in here in this cold cell in the Riga concentration camp. Dear comrades. We live in the hope that you'll soon free us. But today was the most frighting day: they are sending us to Germany. Rescue us from German captivity! We believe that you'll come. We await you!
The detainees were taken at first to Danzig, later to Paderborn....

Born under a the barrel of a machinegun
"In Paderborn concentration camp all the prisoners without exception were forced to drag heavy stones and iron about," Valentina says. "Mama told how the prisoners - in order not to go to work - would make lumps on their legs by beating them with wooden spoons."

From Maria Mikhno's recollections in the book:

I was then readying to give birth, but somehow, I don't know how Masha Lomakina succeeded in doing this, they allowed me to be taken to a maternity hospital. There they laid me right on the floor, though it's true they put down some kind of sackcloth for a bed.
"Mama said that she gave birth to me right under the barrel of a German machinegun," recounts Valentina. "In front of her very eyes a fascist shot a woman and her newborn baby boy. A little boy - so that he wouldn't become a Soviet soldier, and his mother - so that she couldn't give birth to any more... When I showed up in this world, an air-raid started. Everyone who was in the maternity hospital ran away. They threw me on the floor, and mama laid next to me. Later Maria Lomakina, mother's friend came in and saw me, naked and blue from the cold, and she tore up her shirt, wrapped me in her overcoat and took me to the barracks. It was the 25th of January 1945... Maybe I was a white crow, because the Lord allowed me to survive.

"She'll live!"
After a few months the prisoners were freed by the Americans. The allies offered to let many of the prisoners stay and not return to the motherland.

"Our prisoners were afraid of Stalin's policies," explains Valentina. "His example, when he refused to exchange Paulus for his son, declaring that he was a traitor, that was proof. But mama decided to go home to the Ukraine. The homecoming was just like the cinema. Mama came home to her parents with me in her arms. Her father, my grandfather, was a strict man. Therefore mama told him right on the doorstep: 'Papa, I didn't whore around, I was married to Grisha on the front, but he's dead.' But grandpa says: 'Dont' worry, your Grisha is alive.' Mama dropped me from shock. It turned out that my father came to grandpa just before mother's homecoming. He told grandpa that he thought that Masha - grandpa's daughter - was pregnant by him, but Masha was dead. Father said this, and left. But mama was alive... This is how it is in life. On that day they took me to the doctor, I was very weak, and the doctor said that I wouldn't live. Mama came home and cried, but grandpa took me from mother's arms, sent her out of the hut and decided to treat me with folk remedies. What he did, I don't know, but he told mama later: 'She'll live!'. Well, later father came for mother and me and took us to live with his parents."

In 1961 Valentina Grigor'evna arrived in Karaganda and lived with an uncle on her mother's side while she worked as a letter carrier and finished 10th grade. She climbed the ladder to control auditor. She got married and had children who presented her and her husband with four grandchildren.

"Well, that's my life," Valentina sums up with a smile.

But the Soviet spy, the one you're looking for? Who is she?

Valentina Grigor'evna leans over to a book on the table. It opens immediately to the right place. She reads from her mother's recollections:

In the maternity hospital worked one girl. Either a nurse or a nanny. Her name was Asya. She begged the midwife to look in on me from time to time. Asya game me an old blanket to wrap my baby, and later came to me several times. Secretly she'd bring me packets of jelly; we fed the baby with these, because I had no milk. Yes, and why not: they only fed us watery gruel...
"Mama told me that this Asya worked in Soviet intelligence. Under the very noses of the Germans. Just before the end of the war she came up to mama and said that they'd found her out, and that she was on the run. And she took off. And that's all that I know about her. But I'd like to find Asya and bow before her and even kiss her feet. To give a her a human thanks... Don't misunderstand me."

Two years ago Valentina Grigor'evna wrote a letter to the television show Zhdi menya ("wait for me"). She is keeping contact with the Russian talk show through a friend from Vladivostok. The friend is a member of the counsel of the international union of former underage prisoners of fascism. In her last message to her Karagandan friend, she gave Valentina hope that she would really meet Asya. Apparantly the television people have found her and what happened to her. And then Valentina will know her not just by her name.

(Dmitriy Kim, foto Valeriya Kalieva)


7 posted on 04/11/2005 10:54:38 AM PDT by struwwelpeter
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: struwwelpeter

WOW! Feel free to hijack any of my posts anytime you have something this good.


8 posted on 04/11/2005 9:06:03 PM PDT by Valin (The Problem with Reality is the lack of background music)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson