Despite it's questionable origins, I gotta go with the Ben and Jerry's. Cherries Garcia is the BEST! Of course, at 2 pints a day, I'd look like the Goodyear blimp in a month's time.
Ben and Jerry's? No way. I'd rather send my money direct to some pinko twit than to support--even retrospectively--the B&J clique. Blue Bell is an all-American ice cream.