Replies

"Take a random sample of 18 year old American girls and majority of them will not be virgins. So how can you say that "any sex" was "definately against her will"? Does not make any sense."

The mistake you're making here is that your random sample covers a particular period of time - ie, the 18th year or twelve months - whereas Natalee's being forced against her will only covers a couple of hours or less. Morever, since we're talking "willingess" here, a rape is not included in your random sample.

The mistake you're making here is that your random sample covers a particular period of time - ie, the 18th year or twelve months - whereas Natalee's being forced against her will only covers a couple of hours or less. Morever, since we're talking "willingess" here, a rape is not included in your random sample. The point is that since many 18 year old girls are known to volunatrily engage in sex you can't assert that "any sex was definitely agaisnt her will" without any corroborating evidence. Do you believe that "any sex was definitely against her will"? If so, why?